House Commission IX: Proposal to Give Free Meals to TB Patients is Illogical
Deputy Chair of the House of Representatives’ Commission IX, Charles Honoris, has deemed a proposal to make tuberculosis (TBC) patients beneficiaries of the free nutritious meal programme (MBG) as illogical. Charles stated that technically, there is no guarantee that a MBG kitchen is located near the residences of TBC patients. “So technically, I think this will be very difficult, because there is no guarantee that near where a TBC patient lives there is an SPPG kitchen. Thus, there may be other, more appropriate ways to conduct nutritional interventions for TBC patients,” Charles said at the parliament complex in Jakarta on Wednesday (24/6).
He argued that not everything needs to be linked to the MBG programme. Charles noted that community health centres (Puskesmas) exist in every sub-district and village, making them more feasible for assisting TBC patients. “Utilise the Puskesmas to help TBC patients get what they need, whether it is medication or nutritional intervention if required. But providing MBG to TBC patients, I think, is something very unrealistic,” he said.
Charles also highlighted that TBC is a contagious disease. He questioned whether the food containers used in the MBG programme could be reused if they had been used by TBC patients. “TBC is a highly contagious disease, so if the ompreng (food container) is used, will it be returned to the SPPG and reused, or could it potentially transmit the disease to other beneficiaries who are not TBC patients? So, this is a discourse that I think is illogical, and hopefully, the Health Minister was only joking when he proposed it,” he said.
Health Minister Budi Gunadi Sadikin had previously proposed that tuberculosis patients become recipients of the free nutritious meal programme. He said TBC patients have weak immune systems, and nutritious food intake would accelerate their recovery process. “Based on research from international journals and practices already implemented in India and China, people with TBC undergo treatment for 6 to 12 months. Their physical condition is weak, so if they can get sufficient or slightly more nutritional intake, it will strengthen them and speed up recovery,” Budi said at the parliament complex in Jakarta on Tuesday (23/6).
Budi stated that TBC is a deadly disease. According to data, around 126,000 people die from TBC. He admitted to having discussed the proposal with the Head of the National Nutrition Agency (BGN), Nanik S Deyang. “So, every five minutes, two people die from TBC in Indonesia. That is why I spoke with Mrs Nanik about focusing the distribution of MBG on specific targets. She asked me, and I said, ‘Ma’am, MBG really helps me solve health problems,’” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/house-commission-ix-proposal-to-give-free-meals-to-tb-patients-is-illogical-1782294799)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260624155824-32-1372783/komisi-ix-dpr-usul-penderita-tbc-dapat-mbg-tidak-masuk-akal), translated from Indonesian