Hotman Paris Warns Government Over Gas Export Cuts to Singapore: Beware of Arbitration Claims
Jakarta (VIVA) – Prominent Indonesian lawyer Hotman Paris Hutapea has warned the Indonesian Government about cutting gas exports to Singapore. He said Indonesia should be alert to the possibility that Singapore could bring an international arbitration claim as a result.
“Be careful that Indonesia, whether a state-owned enterprise or another party, does not end up being sued in international arbitration and ordered to pay compensation,” Hotman Paris said on Monday (26 October 2026).
He explained that relationships of this kind are generally governed by trade contracts between the two countries, which typically specify an international arbitration body to settle any disputes.
Hotman said potential compensation could take two forms: actual damages and punitive damages.
“Punitive damages under common law, or penalties, can be very large, especially when they concern a country’s gas needs,” he said.
He added that the most far-reaching consequence of taking the matter to international arbitration would be the direct enforcement of rulings against Indonesian assets around the world.
“Even our ships at sea could be seized. For example, an oil tanker of ours sailing at sea could be seized,” he said.
Hotman said this was a consequence of Indonesia being among the countries that have signed the New York Convention.
He also noted that three international arbitration decisions had gone against Indonesian parties so far in 2026. “One state-owned enterprise was ordered to pay more than Rp2 trillion. This was a relatively small case, involving negligence or an alleged breach of contract for failing to supply gas overseas, and the penalty was Rp2.2 trillion. Imagine the losses that could be claimed in arbitration if an entire country’s needs were involved, not to mention fines or punitive damages,” he said.
Hotman predicted that if the Indonesian Government proceeds with the gas export cuts, Singapore would sooner or later take the case to international arbitration.
He advised the government to prepare a professional legal team specialising in commercial litigation to handle the matter.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/hotman-paris-warns-government-over-gas-export-cuts-to-singapore-beware-of-arbitration-claims-1793004772)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1938706-hotman-paris-ingatkan-pemerintah-soal-pangkas-ekspor-gas-ke-singapura-hati-hati-digugat), translated from Indonesian