Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Hotman Paris Urges Indonesia Not to Recognise Foreign Court Judgments

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Hotman Paris Urges Indonesia Not to Recognise Foreign Court Judgments
Image: CNN Indonesia

Advocate Hotman Paris Hutasting has requested that the Special Committee for the Draft Law on Private International Law (RUU HPI) refrain from including provisions that recognise foreign court judgements in Indonesia.

Hotman expressed this view during a meeting to provide public opinion to the RUU HPI Special Committee at the parliamentary complex on Tuesday (29/9).

“From the draft I received from the Special Committee, it appears there is a direction—as this is still a concept—suggesting that foreign court judgements might be recognised as long as they do not conflict with public law,” said Hotman.

According to Hotman, if foreign court judgements are recognised in Indonesia, the public could be severely disadvantaged. He cited the significant costs that Indonesian citizens would have to bear when facing legal proceedings abroad.

He noted that defendants would need to cover expenses for travel, accommodation, and the high costs of hiring legal counsel in the country where the case is being heard.

“Imagine if all Indonesian citizens were sued in foreign countries. Firstly, the costs are extremely high. They would have to travel abroad, pay for flights, hotels, and expensive lawyers there,” he said.

He also highlighted the risks for Indonesian companies sued abroad that are unable to attend court proceedings. Hotman argued that the absence of a defendant could lead to a default judgment.

“If they are sued abroad, they certainly will not want to attend because they cannot afford the costs. If they do not attend, a default judgment—or ‘verstek’ as it is known here—will be issued. Ultimately, this could then be executed here. Therefore, it would be very detrimental to Indonesia if foreign court judgements were to be recognised here,” he stated.

Hotman maintained that according to the provisions of Article 436 of the Reglement op de Rechtsvordering (Rv), foreign court judgements should not be recognised, let alone executed, domestically. However, they could be used as new evidence in a new lawsuit.

“It is very risky. We request that regarding foreign court judgements, even if they do not conflict with the principles of public law, the law should not pass a provision that validates or recognises the authority of foreign court judgements in Indonesia,” said Hotman.

“Once again, the concept in the Private International Law Bill that recognises foreign court judgements will be very detrimental to Indonesian citizens, particularly entrepreneurs, and is inconsistent with our principle of national sovereignty,” he added.

More from 29 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/hotman-paris-urges-indonesia-not-to-recognise-foreign-court-judgments-1790672353)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260929150343-12-1409546/hotman-paris-minta-putusan-pengadilan-asing-tak-diakui-di-indonesia), translated from Indonesian
Print