Hotman Paris Apologises After Belittling Journalists, Faces Police Report
Lawyer Hotman Paris Hutapea, acting as legal counsel for Febrie Adriansyah, a suspect in a corruption case and former Chief Junior Prosecutor, has apologised to journalists and press organisations over remarks widely viewed as demeaning to the journalistic profession.
Hotman’s remarks — including phrases such as ‘do you even have a brain?’, telling a journalist to ‘shut up’ and to ask his grandfather, and labelling journalists ‘cowards’ if they dared not put questions to the National Police headquarters — came under intense scrutiny following the press conference at the Attorney General’s Office (Kejagung) on Friday (17/7).
“An apology from me, Hotman Paris. In light of the appeal from the Indonesian Journalists’ Association (PWI) and fellow journalists, I hereby offer my sincerest apologies for my remarks during the press conference on the case involving the former Chief Junior Prosecutor, when I said ‘do you even have a brain?’”,” Hotman said in a video uploaded to his Instagram account @hotmanparisofficial, quoted on Tuesday (21/7).
Hotman explained the sequence of events that led to the insulting remarks, admitting they came about when he was emotional after being pressed with two consecutive questions.
The first question concerned allegations of a hidden agenda by a certain institution in the Febrie case. Hotman said he had already stated he did not know, or was not in a position to answer, that question. He claimed he became emotional because the second question came whilst he had not yet finished answering the first.
“In the end I lost my temper because I had repeatedly said I did not know. So I replied, ‘do you even have a brain?’. What I meant was that I had already answered that I did not know — because it would be impossible for me to speculate about the hidden agenda of a law enforcement institution,” he said.
Nevertheless, he insisted there was no ill intent behind the statement.
Hotman again apologised to all journalists across Indonesia, noting that he has always maintained close relations with the press.
“But regardless of the facts of what actually happened, when emotions were running high on both sides, I still offer my apology to that journalist and to all journalists’ organisations across Indonesia, because all this time I have been very close to all journalists,” said Hotman.
His remarks at the press conference at the Attorney General’s Office on Friday (17/7) drew strong condemnation for demeaning the journalistic profession.
Several journalists’ professional organisations in Indonesia roundly condemned Hotman’s statement, including the Indonesian Journalists’ Association (PWI), the Legal Journalists’ Association (Iwakum), the Editors-in-Chief Forum and the Indonesian Television Journalists’ Association (IJTI), all of which described his remarks as inappropriate and insulting to journalists.
IJTI Chairman Herik Kurniawan stressed that critical questions from journalists are not an attempt to stir up trouble, but rather part of their professional duty to produce balanced reporting (covering both sides).
Herik highlighted that Hotman’s verbal attack undermined the values of professionalism as well as Articles 1 and 3 of the Journalistic Code of Ethics.
“IJTI reminds everyone of the importance of mutual respect and maintaining ethical communication between professions. Making statements that demean another profession is tantamount to violating the very values of professionalism itself,” he said.
The PWI said it had received Hotman’s apology, but considered that the apology did not automatically resolve the alleged criminal offence committed through his remarks.
Hotman reported to police
The PWI pursued legal action by reporting Hotman to the Metro Jaya Regional Police.
In the report, the PWI alleged that Hotman committed the criminal offence of insult as stipulated in Article 242 of Law Number 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code.
The report was filed on Monday (20/7) and registered under number LP/B/5291/VII/2026/SPKT/POLDA METRO JAYA.
“As we know, yesterday there was an incident that truly hurt and offended the journalistic profession. That is why we, the Central Board of PWI, wish to report the person who said that journalists ‘don’t have a brain’,” said Edison Siahaan, Director of Anti-Violence Against Journalists at the PWI Central Board, at the Metro Jaya Regional Police headquarters on Monday (20/7).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/hotman-paris-apologises-after-belittling-journalists-faces-police-report-1784595124)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260721062030-12-1382944/dikecam-rendahkan-wartawan-hotman-minta-maaf-hingga-dipolisikan), translated from Indonesian