Home Movies
Home Movies
JAKARTA (JP): Many films glorify war and tell stories of how
heroes are born on the battlefield. In essence, their message
seems to be that one side is above the other and thus entitled to
kill its adversaries.
The other side of the story is presented in films which simply
state that war is mindless and every single life is too precious
to be sacrificed.
The two films reviewed below, along with Stanley Kubrick's
Full Metal Jacket, will touch all but the most fervent of
warmongers.
Gallipoli. (Drama/War, 110 minutes, 1981). Starring Mel
Gibson, Mark Lee, Bill Kerr. Directed by Peter Weir.
Young Gibson stars as gifted Australian track athlete Frank
Dunne who is being prepared for the Olympics along with his
friend Archy (Lee). Their trainer Jack (Kerr) also happens to be
Frank's uncle.
When World War I breaks out, the two young idealists fulfill
the nation's call to be soldiers.
Knowing the two young men's gift for speed, the army assigns
them as runners to carry messages in the Gallipoli battlefield in
Turkey.
They then see for themselves the horror of the killing fields
in the Dardanelles, and one of the young men loses his life.
This hard-hitting commentary on war differs from many war
films which venerate their subject matter. The film is not about
the making of heroes or how soldiers use their wits to survive
the battle. Instead, we see how the promise of youth is wasted in
a senseless war (if there is any other kind of war besides that).
The freeze frame final shot of a soldier at the moment of
death is particularly stirring.
Director Weir first made his international name in 1975 with
Picnic at Hanging Rock, the haunting story of the disappearance
of a group of Victorian schoolgirls. He has gone on to cement his
reputation with highly acclaimed works such as Dead Poets
Society, Fearless, The Truman Show and The Year of Living
Dangerously, which also stars Gibson and tells of the turmoil in
Indonesia in 1965.
Yet even among the director's slew of highly praised films,
Gallipoli stands on the front line. A must-see.
The Thin Red Line. (Drama/War, 170 minutes, 1998). Starring
Sean Penn, Adrien Brody, James Caviezel, Ben Chaplin, John
Travolta, John Cusack, Woody Harrelson, George Clooney. Directed
by Terrence Malick.
A group of young American soldiers is brought to the
Guadalcanal battle zone to replace worn-out Marine units during
World War II.
The outcome of the fight for a key airfield will highly
influence the Japanese advance into the Pacific.
Harrowing, gripping, moving war film makes leaves you
forgetting the big-name cast and focusing instead on the
characters they are playing.
The film's highest and most affecting point is when the Allied
soldiers manage to attack a village full of Japanese soldiers.
Instead of being a heroic battle between good and bad guys, the
film shows us the soldiers' confusion when they have no choice
but to kill other human beings for reasons unclear even to them.
The film was released almost at the same time as Steven
Spielberg's Saving Private Ryan. While Spielberg's film is still
about fighting baddies from other countries, The Thin Red Line
says that all soldiers are just people trapped in a fight that is
not really theirs. (Joko E. H. Anwar)
More from 26 November 2000 โ
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/home-movies-1447899208-1274749)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post