Home Affairs Minister on Indonesian Law: Laws Are Made Only After Problems Arise
Home Affairs Minister Tito Karnavian says regulation-making in Indonesia tends to take place only after problems arise. He said the process is more often reactive than anticipatory.
“Law-making in Indonesia usually follows two approaches: a proactive mindset and a reactive mindset. The approach most often taken is reactive. Once there is a problem, people look for a solution, make improvements and draft a law. That is often how it happens,” Tito said at the National Forum on Legal Development at the Ministry of Law’s office in South Jakarta on Thursday (15 October 2026).
He said an anticipatory approach was needed so that lawmakers could identify potential problems and prepare regulations before their effects spread through society. Drafting rules only after a problem has occurred could cause harm, he said.
“What we have yet to get to grips with is how to anticipate problems that may arise and then make rules for them,” he said.
Tito also said law-enforcement officials’ ability to implement regulations was crucial to making them effective.
“Making the right law is only one part of effective law enforcement,” he said.
“I think the third factor is facilities and infrastructure, as well as the budget. We will therefore encourage our colleagues in local government, particularly those with sufficient financial resources, to strengthen their facilities and infrastructure. If you want regulations, you must also provide the facilities and infrastructure, along with the budget,” he added.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/home-affairs-minister-on-indonesian-law-laws-are-made-only-after-problems-arise-1792083053)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8709222/mendagri-bicara-hukum-di-ri-begitu-ada-masalah-baru-dibuat-undang-undang), translated from Indonesian