Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Historic Hajj Scam: Indonesian Pilgrims Forced into Slave Labour on Rubber Plantations

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | History
Historic Hajj Scam: Indonesian Pilgrims Forced into Slave Labour on Rubber Plantations
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia – The enthusiasm of Indonesians to perform the hajj has often been exploited by irresponsible parties seeking profit. Fraud by hajj travel agents is evidently not a new phenomenon; it occurred hundreds of years ago in an extreme form: trapping pilgrims in slavery and forced labour.

This dark case came to light in the late 19th century and involved a leading travel agency of the time, Firma Al-Segaf.

The Return-Fare Loan Scheme

Firma Al-Segaf was founded by a prominent Arab businessman on the Malay Peninsula, Sayid Muhammad bin Ahmad al-Segaf, with its operational base in Singapore. The company was once the primary choice for pilgrims from the Dutch East Indies (now Indonesia) and Singapore. Besides running the pilgrimage travel business, Al-Segaf also managed large-scale rubber plantations on Cocob Island, Johor.

The trouble began when the rubber industry came under pressure due to rising labour wages. To cut operating costs and keep the plantations running, Al-Segaf needed a large supply of cheap labour.

The opportunity arose from the situation of Indonesian pilgrims in Mecca. According to records by historian Henry Chambert-Loir in Naik Haji di Masa Silam (2013), many Indonesian pilgrims were stranded in Mecca after running out of funds to return home, owing to poor financial planning.

Exploiting this vulnerable situation, Al-Segaf offered fresh financial assistance. According to a letter from the Dutch Consul in Jeddah to the Dutch Consul in Singapore dated 27 June 1896, pilgrims were given loans averaging around US$50.

However, this assistance bound the pilgrims into an instalment scheme of 80 payments, with one absolute condition: they were required to work on Al-Segaf’s rubber plantation in Johor until the entire debt was declared settled.

Trapped in a Cycle of Debt and Forced Labour

Upon arriving on Cocob Island, the pilgrims were confronted with a bitter reality. They were forced to work long hours on very low wages. The high cost of living at the plantation site meant their income was never sufficient to cover basic needs while also paying the instalments.

As a result, the pilgrims were forced to take out new loans simply to survive. Mathematically, the scheme made it impossible for them ever to repay their debts, trapping them in slavery and forced labour with no certainty of ever returning home.

Diplomats Step In

Reports of this loan-disguised slavery eventually reached the colonial authorities through the Dutch Consulate in Jeddah. The news was relayed to Batavia (Jakarta), The Hague, and to the British government, which controlled Singapore.

In an archived letter from the Dutch Foreign Minister to the Dutch Consul in Singapore dated 10 April 1895, the Dutch government gave special attention to the matter and urged a thorough investigation into the sale of pilgrims as forced labourers.

The Governor-General of the Dutch East Indies then took firm action to break the chain of the travel operation. One measure proposed was that ships carrying hajj pilgrims should no longer stop over in Singapore, and the British side was asked to tighten regulations on Firma Al-Segaf.

Through this inter-governmental diplomacy and pressure, Firma Al-Segaf’s exploitative practices were finally stopped. The Indonesian pilgrims who had been victimised were repatriated in stages, and Firma Al-Segaf officially went out of the hajj travel business.

More from 26 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/historic-hajj-scam-indonesian-pilgrims-forced-into-slave-labour-on-rubber-plantations-1785048726)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260725221813-4-753829/travel-terkenal-tipu-jemaah-haji-ri-disuruh-kerja-paksa-di-perkebunan), translated from Indonesian
Print