Hercules and Maruarar Clash over Tanah Abang Land Dispute
Gerakan Rakyat Indonesia Bersatu (GRIB) Jaya chairman Hercules Rosario de Marshal and Housing and Settlement Areas Minister Maruarar Sirait (Ara) have traded accusations over a land dispute in Tanah Abang, Central Jakarta.
Hercules said the disputed plot was not vacant land, but had been cleared long ago at a cost of tens of billions of rupiah. He visited the Ministry of Agrarian Affairs and Spatial Planning/National Land Agency (ATR/BPN) to seek clarity on the land’s status.
“Do you know, Ara Sirait, that land is not just empty? I cleared it using money. I paid to clear it. It cost tens of billions. Just so you know. You must not become a minister in a government and then let the government harm the people — harm me again, Ara,” Hercules said in a video posted on GRIB Jaya’s Instagram account, cited on Friday (23 October).
Hercules said he had known Ara before he became a minister in President Prabowo Subianto’s administration. He said Ara had always used his “naughty brain” when he was still in his former political party.
“Now you are a minister in the eighth president’s government. Be aware of yourself; don’t use that naughty brain of yours from when you were still in the red camp. You jumped to the orange camp; I know you. I am a true fighter, a true combatant. For the current government, Hercules is the real fighter, with the red-and-white flag in his blood, no compromise. The government must be led by President Prabowo,” he said.
“Hey, Ara Sirait. If you are right, I support you. But you still want to use that old way of thinking from when you were in the red camp, robbing people all the time. Now you are saving yourself by attaching yourself to the blue camp, and then you want to rob again — and now you are facing me,” Hercules added.
Maruarar, meanwhile, said the government planned to build flats on the disputed land beside the railway near Tanah Abang station in Central Jakarta.
Ara said the land belonged to state-owned railway company PT KAI. He said he had checked its ownership status with the National Land Agency (BPN).
“I have checked with the BPN and Director General Tejo [Director General for Land Dispute and Conflict Resolution at ATR/BPN Iljas Tedjo Prijono], as well as PT KAI President Director Bobby Rasyidin and the head of the State-Owned Enterprises Supervisory Agency, Dony Oskaria. According to them, the Tanah Abang site is clearly a state asset,” Maruarar said on Wednesday (21 October), as quoted by detikcom.
“We will build flats for the public. Indonesia is a state governed by law; the state must be present and use its assets to help the people,” he said.
GRIB Jaya lawyer Wilson Colling previously said, as quoted by detikcom, that the Tanah Abang land belonged to the heirs of the late Iljas Gelar Radjo, namely Sulaeman Efendi, and not to PT KAI.
The claim is based on a land right known as verponding, issued during the Dutch colonial period and converted into Indonesian Verponding No. 946.
According to a PM 1 certificate issued by the local village head, the heirs physically controlled the land from 2004 to 2007 and have continued to occupy it ever since.
Meanwhile, Management Rights (HPL) Nos. 5 and 6, which PT KAI cites as the basis for its claim, were issued in 2008. The HPL titles were issued through an administrative process at the Ministry of Transportation, based on Verponding No. 14399, which Wilson said did not even refer to a location in Tanah Abang.
The Tanah Abang site cannot currently be used for the flats project because the heir, Sulaeman Effendi, with the assistance of Rosaria de Marshall, or Hercules, and the GRIB Jaya central board’s Legal and Advocacy Team, is pursuing a lawsuit. The case is registered as No. 241/Pdt.G/2026/PN Jkt.Pst.
House of Representatives calls for BPN involvement
Ahmad Irawan, a member of Commission II of the House of Representatives (DPR), has called on the National Land Agency to mediate between Hercules Rosario de Marshal and Minister Ara over the Tanah Abang land dispute.
He said that if the land in question had become a state asset, its ownership should be recorded by the Directorate General of State Assets at the Ministry of Finance. However, given the competing claims by Hercules and Ara, he said mediation should be handled by the agency led by ATR/BPN Minister and head Nusron Wahid.
“If there are different claims to the rights — for example, between Hercules’s side and the government — then there is a dispute between them. If there is a dispute, the parties can be mediated by the National Land Agency,” Irawan told reporters by phone on Friday (23 October).
Irawan said Hercules and Ara could ask the BPN about the land’s ownership history, as the agency was the most authoritative body to explain its status.
“They are the most authoritative institution to provide an explanation about the status of the land,” he said.
He also said they could ask the BPN for the warkah, or official documents forming the legal basis for land ownership.
“If they are asked to resolve it, they can also ask the BPN about the warkah. By that, I mean the land’s ownership history; they can ask the BPN about it,” Irawan said.
Irawan said Commission II worked with the Ministry of ATR/BPN, but that in this case the commission would leave the matter to the BPN. He stressed that every institution had its own duties and functions.
“It is not that we lack authority, but every state institution has its own duties and functions. This is a concrete case that must of course be resolved by the government or the courts. We oversee land policy in general, not concrete, individual cases,” Irawan said.
At the time of writing, the BPN had not issued an official statement on the land dispute between Hercules and Minister Ara.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/hercules-and-maruarar-clash-over-tanah-abang-land-dispute-1792759963)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261023152414-20-1418897/adu-mulut-hercules-dan-maruarar-terkait-lahan-tanah-abang), translated from Indonesian