Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Health Ministry's Plain Packaging Plan Could Hamper Investment and Economic Growth

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Health Ministry's Plain Packaging Plan Could Hamper Investment and Economic Growth
Image: Media Indonesia

A plan by the Ministry of Health to standardise the design and colour of cigarette packaging, known as plain packaging, through a draft ministerial regulation is feared to have the potential to suppress investment and disrupt economic growth targets. The proposed policy is also expected to impact the advertising and creative industries.

Susilo Dwihatmanto, Head of the Advertising Supervisory Body at the Indonesian Advertising Companies Association (P3I), revealed that advertising spending contributions from the cigarette and e-cigarette industry have declined sharply over the past decade. The role of the tobacco industry, which was previously a major contributor to advertising spending, has now been displaced, although for decades the sector contributed significantly to the advertising industry.

Although the current share of advertising spending from the tobacco sector is already below 10%, Susilo believes the plan for new regulations such as plain packaging still raises major concerns. According to him, the policy could trigger a domino effect on the wider advertising business ecosystem, especially for e-cigarette products which have been actively promoting in recent years.

He added that restrictions on the tobacco industry in Indonesia have already been implemented in multiple layers and are increasingly stringent over time. Various non-fiscal rules, such as restrictions on television advertising airtime and the prohibition of billboards on several main roads in Jakarta, coupled with fiscal policies like excise tax increases, have put significant pressure on the sector.

According to Susilo, the tobacco products industry is now a fully regulated sector. He believes the situation will become even more difficult if the plain packaging policy is implemented. “I think the Ministry of Health is being reckless if this regulation is passed. Because it will cause tens of millions more people to become unemployed. So it’s not just a matter of cigarettes,” Susilo said.

He also emphasised that packaging has a strategic function that goes far beyond its role as a product protector. Packaging is a communication medium that can provide information and education to consumers directly. “Packaging design provides identity to a product or brand, a communication tool that works without words. So when we see packaging, it explains whether it’s an e-cigarette or a regular cigarette, filtered or non-filtered, including the colours, logo, typography, the packaging design builds brand identity,” he explained.

Furthermore, Susilo argued that removing visual elements from packaging would make all products appear uniform to consumers, even though products differ in terms of raw materials, quality, and target price segments.

Meanwhile, Hermawan Sutanto, Chairman of the Indonesian Video Streaming Association (AVISI), assessed that the policy could hinder the development of the national creative industry, which the government is currently pushing to improve competitiveness and attract investment. “This is very counterproductive amidst the government’s efforts to increase investment value, develop the creative economy, and encourage national film industry players to grow and go international,” he said in a press statement.

The statement reflects concerns that several provisions in the draft regulation have not fully considered the impact on aspects beyond health. Amidst the government’s efforts to maintain economic growth momentum and increase investment, business players believe that regulatory synergy between ministries and institutions, setting aside sectoral egos, is needed so that every policy issued remains aligned with the national development agenda.

AVISI also requested that the Ministry of Health open a wider dialogue with stakeholders directly affected by the regulation. “We also ask the Ministry of Health to consider providing an exemption from the provisions of Article 24 for film and art products so that the Indonesian film industry can continue to develop,” he added. In addition to requesting an exemption for film and art products, AVISI urged that video streaming and film industry players be actively involved in the discussion of the draft ministerial regulation, particularly regarding articles deemed potentially burdensome to the industry.

These concerns arise as the government is currently striving to boost investment and drive higher economic growth. The administration of Prabowo Subianto and Gibran Rakabuming Raka is targeting economic growth of up to 8%. In an official statement released on Friday (5/6/2026), the Ministry of Health stated that it is continuing the drafting of the Ministerial Regulation on the Inclusion of Health Warnings and Information on Tobacco and Electronic Cigarette Products. The ministry asserted that the drafting process is being conducted openly and involves various stakeholders. “All input submitted during the regulatory drafting process has been taken into consideration by the government. However, in principle, health policy must prioritise the protection of the public, especially children, from the risk of addiction and the adverse effects of tobacco consumption,” said the Acting Director General of Disease Control at the Ministry of Health, dr. Andi Saguni. However, this statement is considered inconsistent with conditions on the ground, amidst criticism from various parties who believe the draft regulation has the potential to disrupt the industry.

More from 11 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/health-ministrys-plain-packaging-plan-could-hamper-investment-and-economic-growth-1786463489)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/ekonomi/920711/rencana-aturan-kemenkes-berpotensi-menghambat-investasi-dan-target-pertumbuhan-ekonomi), translated from Indonesian
Print