Hanura Proposes Combined Open-Closed Proportional System for 2029 Legislative Election
The Hanura Party is pushing for changes to the legislative electoral system for 2029, moving away from a fully open proportional system. Hanura is proposing a combined system that gives political parties a role in determining legislative candidates while still allowing candidates to win seats based on their vote tally.
This was conveyed by Hanura Deputy Chairman Patrice Rio Capella following a consolidation event in the Riau Islands. According to him, a change in the system is necessary to improve the quality of members of the House of Representatives (DPR) and Regional Legislative Councils (DPRD) in the 2029 elections.
‘Elections should improve the quality of their outcomes each time. We hope that in the 2029 elections, the quality of the DPR, and the provincial and regency/city DPRD will also improve,’ Rio Capella said, as quoted by detikSumut on Tuesday evening (11/8/2026).
Rio assessed that the current open proportional system is too much like a ‘free market’, because legislative candidates can compete directly for votes. He argued that this situation has the potential to sideline active party cadres who lose out due to a lack of capital.
‘Good people, activists within the party, may be good, but they lose out on capital. So they are pushed aside and defeated by people who do not follow the party process and do not develop their party at all,’ he said.
According to him, Hanura wants to restore the role of political parties in determining quality legislative candidates. He mentioned that one option being considered is a semi-open or combined system, where the first seat is given to the candidate based on the party’s list order, while subsequent seats are awarded based on the highest number of votes.
‘If a party gets two seats, the first seat is given to the number one candidate on the list, and the next seat is determined by the highest number of votes. In our view, this gives the party a chance to put forward its quality cadres, without closing the opportunity for people to fight for additional seats based on vote count,’ he explained.
He gave an example: if a party only wins one seat, that seat goes to the number one candidate on the list. However, if the party wins two seats, the second seat can be given to the candidate with the next highest number of votes, rather than automatically going to the number two candidate on the list.
‘This way, there is an appreciation and a culture is built where people become legislative candidates by building up their party first. Not just moving between political parties relying solely on having a lot of money,’ he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/hanura-proposes-combined-open-closed-proportional-system-for-2029-legislative-election-1786485028)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8614546/hanura-usul-sistem-pemilu-2029-gabungkan-proporsional-terbuka-tertutup), translated from Indonesian