Halfway Through Iran-US MOU: Hormuz Pushes Conflict into a New Phase
Note: This article is the writer’s personal opinion and does not reflect the views of the CNBCIndonesia.com editorial team.
The Islamabad Memorandum (MOU) between Iran and the United States, mediated by Pakistan and signed on 17 June 2026, has now entered the halfway point of its two-month pause in increasingly fragile condition. Formally, the agreement remains in force, but its effectiveness continues to decline.
In recent days, the United States launched two waves of attacks on Iranian territory — around 140 targets on 11 July and dozens more on 13 July — while the IRGC retaliated by striking US-linked installations in Kuwait and Bahrain. Iran subsequently declared the Strait of Hormuz closed, pushing shipping traffic to its lowest level in five weeks. Markets reacted immediately. After touching US$70.5 per barrel on 3 July, Brent crude climbed back to around US$80 per barrel on 13 July, rising roughly 13 per cent in just ten trading days.
The main problem is no longer whether the MOU remains formally valid, but that military dynamics are developing far faster than the diplomatic mechanism established by the Islamabad Memorandum. Exactly as warned in an analysis on 2 June 2026, Hormuz has now become the arena for a struggle over the permanent security architecture of the Middle East, no longer merely a point of tactical tension.
Hormuz at the Heart of the Dispute
Many analyses still place the ceasefire at the heart of the Islamabad Memorandum. Yet the real issue is Hormuz. For Washington, the principle of freedom of navigation requires this corridor to remain open without any single country controlling access. Conversely, for Tehran, Hormuz is a strategic asset that provides bargaining power. Iran does not need to close the strait entirely; limited disruption to shipping is enough to raise costs, insurance premiums and political pressure.
What is being contested is no longer simply access to shipping, but who has the right to set the rules on security, navigation and governance of one of the world’s most strategic energy corridors.
Recent developments have clarified this shift. After Iran again declared Hormuz closed, the United States reimposed a blockade on shipping bound for or originating from Iran, while still guaranteeing international shipping under the protection of the US Navy. President Donald Trump also announced plans to impose a 20 per cent levy on vessels transiting the strait. Both sides are no longer merely asserting their political claims, but beginning to enforce their own rules over Hormuz.
Why Compromise Is Increasingly Difficult
For Tehran, any settlement must acknowledge its strategic interests in Hormuz. Its minimum position comprises three elements: no obstruction of Iranian oil exports, a halt to US offensive operations during the MOU period, and de facto recognition that security arrangements for Hormuz cannot be made without taking Iran’s interests into account.
Conversely, President Trump must balance two conflicting interests: avoiding a prolonged war that could trigger a surge in energy prices and inflation ahead of the November 2026 midterm elections, whilst demonstrating that the United States remains the principal guarantor of freedom of international navigation. Washington’s progression from limited strikes to a maritime blockade of Iran shows that the space for compromise is narrowing on both sides.
Three Scenarios Ahead of Mid-August
There are at least three scenarios. Scenario A: Technical Compromise. Both parties reach an understanding on managing Hormuz through an operational mechanism or regional mediation. To date, there are no signs pointing in that direction.
Scenario B: Armed Deadlock. The MOU survives legally but loses its influence over the parties’ behaviour, while clashes continue without developing into direct confrontation. This scenario has already been overtaken. The reciprocal attacks on 11 and 13 July show the conflict has entered a stage of direct military engagement.
Scenario C: Open Escalation. The conflict intensifies as each party begins unilaterally enforcing its own security rules over Hormuz. Iran’s closure of the strait, followed by the US maritime blockade of Iranian shipping and the planned transit levy on vessels, indicates that dynamics on the ground have moved towards this scenario.
This change requires an update to the scenarios previously outlined. The question is no longer whether the transition to Scenario C will occur, but whether the current escalation is merely temporary positioning to strengthen bargaining power, or the point at which the Islamabad Memorandum’s effectiveness ends.
A New Phase, Not a Return to Square One
The conflict is not returning to the situation before the MOU. Rather, the centre of the dispute has shifted from ending the war to contesting authority over the security, navigation and governance of the Strait of Hormuz. That rivalry is now being pursued through the use of military force, control of shipping lanes and economic pressure.
The rise in oil prices back to around US$80 per barrel shows that markets are beginning to view the Hormuz dispute as a structural problem with the potential to disrupt global energy stability, no longer merely a series of temporary military incidents.
As the MOU pause period approaches its end in mid-August, the central question is no longer whether the agreement remains formally valid, but whether both parties are still able to halt the escalation and return to the resolution mechanisms agreed in the Islamabad Memorandum. If current developments continue, the MOU will likely end not through a political decision to cancel it, but because it can no longer control the parties’ behaviour.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/halfway-through-iran-us-mou-hormuz-pushes-conflict-into-a-new-phase-1783990243)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260714063851-14-750556/separuh-jalan-mou-iran-as-hormuz-bawa-konflik-ke-babak-baru), translated from Indonesian