Hajj Quota Trial: BPK Auditor Explains Four Stages for Calculating State Losses
Indonesian Supreme Audit Agency (BPK) auditor Muhammad Ramadhani explained the four stages for calculating state financial losses while appearing as an expert witness in the alleged corruption case involving additional Hajj quotas for 2023–2024. He said the process runs from pre-planning through to the reporting of audit findings.
The hearing was held at the Jakarta Corruption Court on Tuesday (27 October 2026). The defendants are former Religious Affairs Minister Yaqut Cholil Qoumas; Yaqut’s former special staff member Ishfah Abidal Azis, also known as Gus Alex; Asrul Azis Taba, chairman of the Kesthuri Association; and Ismail Adham, operations director of PT Makassar Toraja (Maktour).
Prosecutors first asked about the investigative audit standards used by the BPK to calculate state losses. Ramadhani said the calculation process is guided by BPK Regulations No. 1 of 2017 and No. 1 of 2020, as well as expert testimony.
“We follow the State Financial Audit Standards, as stipulated in BPK Regulation No. 1 of 2017. We also follow BPK Regulation No. 1 of 2020 on Investigative Audits, the Calculation of State Losses and the Provision of Expert Testimony in the audit process,” Ramadhani said in response to a prosecutor’s question about the applicable standards.
Ramadhani said the calculation also refers to Law No. 17 of 2003 on State Finance and Law No. 1 of 2004 on the State Treasury. He outlined four stages, beginning with pre-planning, which involves understanding the case’s construction and the evidence obtained by the authorised agency.
At this initial stage, he said, auditors determine whether the case falls within the scope of state finances and assess whether the case’s construction is consistent with the evidence obtained by the relevant agency. They then analyse the case and discuss their findings before deciding whether to accept or reject a request to calculate state losses.
The second stage is planning, during which auditors prepare implementation guidelines. Its outputs are an audit assignment letter and an audit programme. The third stage is the audit itself.
“During the audit, we examine the case’s construction, analyse and evaluate the audit evidence, obtain additional evidence, and draw up a draft conclusion. We then discuss the draft conclusion in relation to the alleged irregularities and the amount of the loss. The output at this stage is a draft conclusion,” Ramadhani said.
The fourth and final stage is reporting. This involves preparing a draft audit report and finalising the calculation of state financial losses. The output is an investigative audit report for the purpose of calculating state losses.
In this case, former minister Yaqut is charged with causing state financial losses of Rp622,090,207,166.41 (around Rp622 billion) in the alleged corruption involving additional Hajj quotas for 2023–2024. Prosecutors allege that he acted together with Kesthuri Association chairman Asrul Azis Taba, his former special staff member Ishfah Abidal Azis, also known as Gus Alex, and Maktour operations director Ismail Adham.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/hajj-quota-trial-bpk-auditor-explains-four-stages-for-calculating-state-losses-1793080426)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8725921/sidang-kuota-haji-auditor-bpk-jelaskan-4-tahap-penghitungan-kerugian-negara), translated from Indonesian