Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Hajj Observer Says Scrapping 'Lunas Tunda Ganti' Scheme Requires Formal Regulation, Not Just Statement

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Hajj Observer Says Scrapping 'Lunas Tunda Ganti' Scheme Requires Formal Regulation, Not Just Statement
Image: Republika

JAKARTA — The Indonesian Ministry of Hajj and Umrah (Kemenhaj) has abolished the pay-full-deferred-replacement mechanism in the organisation of special hajj pilgrimage. The policy was taken to close loopholes for irregularities long exploited by rogue Special Hajj Pilgrimage Organisers (PIHK), while also ensuring pilgrims depart according to their quota registration order.

Deputy Minister of Hajj and Umrah (Wamenhaj) Dahnil Anzar Simanjuntak said the decision forms part of reforms to special hajj governance to make it more transparent, fair and accountable.

Commenting on the policy, hajj observer Mustolih Siradj said the abolition of the scheme is indeed aimed at addressing problems to protect special hajj pilgrims, so that they gain certainty over their departure. Secondly, it seeks to close loopholes amid alleged manipulation carried out by rogue actors through the pay-full-deferred-replacement mechanism.

“But what the Deputy Minister has announced should also be accompanied by the necessary instruments. The first is that there must, of course, be a regulation that updates the governance of special hajj pilgrimage,” Mustolih told Republika on Wednesday (22/7/2026).

He stressed that the abolition of the scheme would have a proper legal basis only if codified in a ministerial regulation. He urged that these policies not be handled merely through statements, but be followed up in a more concrete form, namely a legal product serving as the overarching legal umbrella.

According to him, the steps announced by the Deputy Minister would only be relevant if the socialisation and confirmation of departing special hajj pilgrims are given sufficient lead time, at least six months in advance.

“Special hajj pilgrims, whether special or regular, are announced well in advance; the quota has already been set, and the hajj timeline has already been conveyed by the Saudi authorities — we only need to follow it,” he said.

More from 22 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/hajj-observer-says-scrapping-lunas-tunda-ganti-scheme-requires-formal-regulation-not-just-statement-1784699541)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/tik8bx483/penghapusan-lunas-tunda-ganti-pada-haji-khusus-dinilai-tak-cukup-lewat-pernyataan), translated from Indonesian
Print