Hajar Aswad Said to Have Fallen from Heaven, Here's the Scientific Explanation
The Hajar Aswad has existed since the time of Prophet Ibrahim and holds a significant role in Islamic history. Religiously, Muslims believe this black stone, embedded in the corner of the Kaaba, originated from heaven.
However, what if the origins of this sacred stone are examined through a scientific lens? Scientists worldwide have long conducted in-depth studies to uncover the category and origin of the rock.
Some experts argue that the Hajar Aswad falls into the category of a meteorite. This conclusion is not without reason, as it attempts to align the religious narrative that the stone ‘fell from the sky’ or heaven. Furthermore, historical facts show traces of meteorites found not far from the Kaaba region.
In a study titled “New Light on the Origin of the Holy Black Stone of the Ka’ba” (1980), E. Thomsen revealed interesting facts. He referred to the findings of a researcher named Philby in the Al-Hodeidah region in 1932. Philby discovered a meteor impact crater, which later became known as the Wabar crater.
The crater is reported to have a diameter of more than 100 metres, with several rock fragments scattered around the crater and the surrounding desert area.
Scientifically, the rock fragments in the Wabar crater were formed from the melting of sand and silica mixed with nickel elements. Thomsen explained that this combination of chemicals creates an inner layer that is white, while the outer part is encased in a black shell.
The deep black colour on the outer part of the rock comes from the nickel component produced by the explosion of Nickel and Ferrum (iron) in outer space.
Interestingly, Thomsen assesses that the physical characteristics of these Wabar meteorite fragments are very similar to the physical description of the Hajar Aswad. In Islamic history, the Hajar Aswad is said to have originally been bright white but gradually turned black by absorbing human sins.
From a scientific perspective, the white radiance once visible on the Hajar Aswad likely originated from exposure to the core or the inner layer of the rock’s chemical mixture. This inner white layer would not last long against environmental exposure, so over time, its position shifted downwards, leaving the dominant black outer layer.
As for the white spots still visible on the Hajar Aswad today, they are analysed as remnants of glass and sandstone that crystallised due to the impact of high-temperature collisions.
“The meteor stone is likely the same stone as the Hajar Aswad,” Thomsen wrote in his study report.
Other research has also attempted to trace the age of the rock. Analysis results show that the geological age of this rock is consistent with the timeframe of observations by ancient Arab societies, and there is a possibility that the stone was brought to Makkah via ancient trade routes through Oman.
Nevertheless, the theory stating that the Hajar Aswad is a meteorite continues to spark debate and has weaknesses in the eyes of some scientists. Criticism of this theory arises because the general characteristics of meteorites usually do not float in water, are not easily broken into small fragments, and have a different resistance to natural erosion processes compared to the actual physical characteristics of the Hajar Aswad.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/hajar-aswad-said-to-have-fallen-from-heaven-heres-the-scientific-explanation-1782525051)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/tech/20260626172444-37-746078/hajar-aswad-disebut-jatuh-dari-surga-begini-penjelasan-ilmiahnya), translated from Indonesian