Growing Stocks Are Not Always Good Investments
There is a type of stock that almost always attracts investor attention. Companies with rapidly growing profits, increasingly recognised products, expanding markets, and a promising future often become the centre of attention. When growth persists for several years, share prices can also rise very quickly. For investors, this situation appears simple: find a great company, buy its shares, and wait for business growth to lift the investment value. However, Benjamin Graham reminds us that there is one part that is often forgotten: the price that must be paid to obtain that growth.
In ‘The Intelligent Investor’, Graham explains that investors buying growth stocks are actually making an important trade-off. They are not only using a company’s past records as a basis for valuation, but are also incorporating estimates of the company’s ability to generate even greater profits in the future. In other words, part of the stock’s value comes from something that has not yet happened. A company may indeed grow, but investors must estimate how much that growth will be and how long it can be sustained.
This is where growth stocks become more complicated than they appear. Assessing a company with a long history of earnings requires analysis; assessing a company whose value depends largely on future growth requires a higher level of confidence. Small errors in estimating growth can result in a massive difference between the true value and the price paid. Therefore, Graham does not reject growth stocks, but places them within a stricter framework.
A company may have an excellent business, a strong competitive position, and attractive growth prospects, yet its shares can still be an unattractive investment if the market has already paid too much for all those expectations. Graham demonstrates that the risk characteristics of a stock are not determined solely by the quality of the company. Risk also changes according to the stock price in the market. The greater the public enthusiasm and the faster the share price rises compared to the company’s earnings growth, the greater the speculative element embedded in that price.
Imagine a company whose profits grow by 15 per cent in a year. Investors are then so impressed that its share price rises by 50 per cent. The company is indeed becoming more valuable, but the share price has increased far faster than the earnings. If such conditions persist, new investors are no longer buying a business based on realised performance, but are buying expectations of potential performance. This distinction is vital because expectations tend to change much faster than company fundamentals.
Graham even emphasises that even large, well-established companies are not immune to this issue. High-quality investment companies can transform into stocks with different risk characteristics when the market provides an excessive valuation. This means that a good company and a cheap stock are two different things. A good company can become an expensive stock, while a struggling company can become a cheap stock if the market price falls much further than the decline in business value.
The greatest challenge in buying growth stocks is the need to foresee the future with sufficient accuracy. Graham does not say that the future cannot be analysed; rather, he acknowledges that competent future earnings forecasts can serve as a valid basis for valuation. The problem arises when these forecasts are too optimistic and the share price leaves little room for error. Therefore, if investors use future projections, Graham emphasises the need to make conservative estimates.
This principle brings us back to the ‘margin of safety’. Growth stock investors still require protection against error. If an investor expects a company’s profits to rise sharply, they must ask whether the current share price still provides enough room if growth turns out to be lower than expected. If the projected growth fails to materialise, how much loss in value must be endured? Such questions are far more important than simply asking whether the company has good prospects.
The margin of safety always changes according to the price. At a certain price, a stock may provide sufficient safety. As the price rises, that margin narrows. If the price continues to climb, the margin of safety can eventually disappear entirely. This is why Graham does not view company quality as a sufficient reason to buy a stock at any price. Even companies with excellent prospects must be purchased with consideration for the price.
A common mistake is equating growth with security. When a company records profit growth for several years, investors may feel that the trend will continue. The share price is then deemed safe because the company appears successful. However, Graham warns that current gains are not necessarily synonymous with long-term earning power. Business conditions that are exceptionally good can make profits appear much stronger than the company’s ability under normal conditions.
Therefore, looking at only one or two years of growth is insufficient. Investors need to understand whether that growth stems from sustainable business strength or is merely the result of specific circumstances. If profits increase due to industry cycles…
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/growing-stocks-are-not-always-good-investments-1790009547)
Originally published by vibiznews.com (https://vibiznews.com/index.php/2026/09/21/saham-bertumbuh-tidak-selalu-menjadi-investasi-yang-baik/), translated from Indonesian