GRC, Independence, and the Fortress of Hajj Trust
Jakarta (ANTARA) - There is one important lesson from the issues surrounding Lembaga Tabung Haji (LTH) in Malaysia: the vastness of funds, a long history, and a high reputation of an institution do not automatically guarantee strong governance.
In the management of community funds, what determines the resilience of an institution is not merely how much profit it can generate, but how robust the system is in ensuring that profits are obtained healthily, risks are controlled, regulations are obeyed, and the entire process is accountable.
In this context, I see that the Hajj Financial Management Agency (BPKH) possesses a more solid institutional foundation because it is built upon three main pillars: governance, risk management, and compliance (GRC).
This is the primary thesis that must be emphasised: BPKH is not robust solely due to its financial performance, but because its GRC system, independence, and oversight mechanisms are designed to protect pilgrims’ funds from the risks of error, deviation, or short-term interest pressures.
Therefore, the experience of LTH should be read as a mirror to strengthen BPKH, rather than merely a comparison to show who is better.
Reputation is not enough
Lembaga Tabung Haji is one of the oldest and most well-known Hajj fund management institutions in the Islamic world. However, the results of Malaysia’s Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCI), as summarised in the article ‘Politics, Piety and Poor Governance: Malaysia’s Hajj Fund Reckoning’ in Islamic Finance News on 5 August 2026, show serious problems in its financial management.
In 2017, LTH was reported to have suffered losses of approximately RM1.4 billion, yet it continued to distribute grants of around RM2.27 billion. After various accounting adjustments, LTH reported a profit of approximately RM3 ever since. The RCI also highlighted a decline in investment value estimated to reach RM4.26 billion.
If these findings are true as reported, the issue is not just about the numbers. The main problem is the failure of the system to ensure that the figures presented truly reflect economic reality.
This is where governance becomes vital. Because when financial reports begin to be influenced by the need to maintain an image of success, what is threatened is not just the balance sheet, but also public trust.
Managing the trust
BPKH was established based on Law Number 34 of 2014, with an institutional design that places Hajj financial management within a public law framework.
The consequence is clear: Hajj funds must be managed according to the principles of Sharia, prudence, benefit, transparency, and accountability. However, in my view, the strength of BPKH does not stop at legal norms. That strength must be seen through an increasingly measurable GRC system.
Governance ensures that authority, responsibility, decision-making processes, and oversight have a clear structure. No strategic decision should depend on a single person or a single interest.
Risk management ensures that every investment does not only ask, “How large is the profit?” but also, “What is the risk? How large is the possibility of loss? What is the impact on the pilgrims’ funds? And how is it mitigated?”
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/grc-independence-and-the-fortress-of-hajj-trust-1788498170)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5725579/grc-kemandirian-dan-benteng-amanah-haji), translated from Indonesian