Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

GP Ansor Warns Proposed Nicotine and Tar Rules Could Sacrifice Tobacco Farmers

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Economy
GP Ansor Warns Proposed Nicotine and Tar Rules Could Sacrifice Tobacco Farmers
Image: Media Indonesia

The Legal Aid Institute of the GP Ansor Youth Movement (LBH PP GP Ansor) has stated it is preparing legal action if the government proceeds with three draft regulations on tobacco control. The move is deemed necessary because several provisions in the drafts are considered to exceed the mandate of the law and could potentially harm farmers and the tobacco industry.

The three regulations are the Draft Coordinating Minister for Human Development and Cultural Affairs Regulation on nicotine and TAR limits, the Draft Minister of Health Decree on additives in tobacco products, and health warnings and information on tobacco products leading to plain packaging. All are derivative rules of Law Number 17 of 2023 on Health.

Legal practitioner Abdul Hakim from LBH PP GP Ansor said the regulations on nicotine and TAR limits, as well as plain packaging, would impact the entire tobacco ecosystem, from farmers and businesses to the industry. He argued that if nicotine and TAR limits are imposed without considering the characteristics of local tobacco, industry demand will shift significantly to imported raw materials because domestic tobacco will struggle to meet the requirements. ‘Everyone will be harmed. If this rule is applied, demand for domestic tobacco will decrease,’ Hakim said in an official statement on Thursday.

Hakim assessed that the government has so far failed to show support for tobacco farmers. He noted that farmers contribute significantly to state revenue through tobacco excise but have not received equal treatment compared to other agricultural commodities. ‘Tobacco farmers are positioned like stepchildren. Their excise is collected, but the farmers are not protected. Even today, tobacco farmers do not receive subsidised fertiliser like other commodity farmers, even though the contribution of tobacco excise to the state is enormous,’ he explained.

Hakim also highlighted the legal basis for setting maximum nicotine and TAR limits, which he said is not explicitly regulated in the Health Law. On this basis, he considers that the derivative rules detailing nicotine and TAR levels potentially exceed the law’s mandate. ‘Therefore, these regulations must be tested. The path could be through the Supreme Court or the Constitutional Court. However, in my view, the most appropriate is to test the law at the Constitutional Court because the core issue lies in the multi-interpretable norm. A ministerial regulation should not exceed the mandate of the law,’ he stated.

He also questioned the plain packaging plan, which he said could clash with intellectual property rights and brand identity. According to him, if the government persists with this policy, a judicial review is a step worth considering.

Before pursuing legal channels, Lesbumi PBNU submitted a petition directly to the Ministry of Health as a form of rejection of the latest tobacco regulations. They also sent the petition by post to President Prabowo Subianto, Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka, the Speaker of the House of Representatives, the Coordinating Ministry for Human Development and Culture, the Head of the Presidential Staff Office, and several parliamentary commissions, as well as associations of provincial, district, and city governments across Indonesia.

Lesbumi PBNU Chairman Jadul Maula said the submission of the petition to the Ministry of Health is the organisation’s initial step in conveying public aspirations. However, if all the input provided is not accommodated in the regulatory drafting process, Lesbumi does not rule out taking legal action. ‘We prioritise dialogue and hope the government truly listens to the aspirations of the affected communities. But if the regulation is forced through without considering the economic, social, and cultural impacts, then various constitutional steps will be considered as part of our effort to fight for the people’s interests,’ he said.

He added that tobacco control regulations should be drafted proportionally by considering all affected aspects, not just health. This is because millions of farmers, labourers, and business actors who depend on the tobacco sector also have the right to protection in every government policy formulation.

More from 9 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/gp-ansor-warns-proposed-nicotine-and-tar-rules-could-sacrifice-tobacco-farmers-1783605050)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/nusantara/909273/gp-ansor-sebut-usulan-aturan-nikotin-dan-tar-korbankan-petani-tembakau), translated from Indonesian
Print