Government Tells Constitutional Court Pre-trial Reviews Cannot Be Staggered
Deputy Law Minister Edward Omar Sharif Hiariej (Eddy Hiariej), representing the President, gave evidence at a Constitutional Court hearing on challenges relating to the Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP). Eddy said pre-trial review applications could not be staggered.
He made the remarks at a hearing on cases 313, 316 and 317/PUU-XXIV/2026 at the Constitutional Court building in Central Jakarta on Monday (19 October 2026). He was accompanied in court by National Police Legal Division chief Inspector General Ahrie Sonta.
Constitutional Court Chief Justice Suhartoyo initially asked whether someone could apply for pre-trial review more than once. He gave the example of a person seeking review of a further coercive measure after an earlier pre-trial ruling.
For instance, a suspect might challenge their designation as a suspect, and a pre-trial judge might issue a ruling. If investigators then take another coercive measure, such as conducting a search or seizure, Suhartoyo asked whether the person could seek a further pre-trial review of that measure.
“If a coercive measure is taken only after the pre-trial proceedings—for example, a further coercive measure introduced while a pre-trial case is under way—would that also be barred?” Suhartoyo asked.
Eddy replied that the House of Representatives’ initial draft of the Criminal Procedure Code Bill would have allowed a person to seek pre-trial review for each coercive measure. He said the House draft listed six types of coercive measure, and the Government added three more during deliberations, bringing the total under the Code to nine.
“Your Honours, imagine if each coercive measure could be challenged through one pre-trial review. With nine coercive measures, there could be nine pre-trial reviews. That would delay the resolution of a case, and delaying the resolution of a case is the same as delaying justice,” Eddy said.
Eddy said the Government had proposed allowing only one pre-trial review so that the determination of the main case would not be delayed. However, he acknowledged that a question arose when a further coercive measure was taken after the first pre-trial ruling.
“We therefore decided within the Government, together with law enforcement agencies, that there should be only one application covering all the same matters. But the Chief Justice’s question is relevant: what if a coercive measure is taken after the first pre-trial ruling?” he said.
He said applicants could not divide into separate applications challenges to coercive measures that had already been taken before the pre-trial application was filed. In his view, doing so would be a tactic to circumvent the rule.
“Let us say that, by the time of the first pre-trial review, there has already been a suspect designation, a search and a seizure. Those cannot be challenged bit by bit. That would be a way of gaming the system. There can be only one application. They can all be tested effectively, but they cannot then be staggered one by one,” he said.
However, Eddy said a person could apply for pre-trial review again in respect of a coercive measure taken after the first ruling. He said the Criminal Procedure Code provided for this possibility.
“But the Chief Justice’s question is an interesting one: what if another coercive measure is taken after the pre-trial ruling? That can be brought before a pre-trial court. In other words, before the hearing begins or the case is registered with the court, pre-trial review can still be sought,” he said.
In case 313, the applicant is challenging Article 62 paragraphs 5 and 6 of the Criminal Procedure Code, which govern the transfer of cases from investigators to prosecutors. The applicant in case 316 is challenging Article 163 paragraph 1(e), which provides that proceedings on the merits cannot begin while a pre-trial review remains unresolved.
The applicant in case 317 is challenging Article 158 of the Code, concerning pre-trial review. The applicant has asked the Constitutional Court to rule that grounds for review already in existence before an application is filed cannot be brought separately or staggered across multiple applications.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/government-tells-constitutional-court-pre-trial-reviews-cannot-be-staggered-1792410660)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8714319/jawab-gugatan-di-mk-pemerintah-jelaskan-praperadilan-tak-boleh-dicicil), translated from Indonesian