Government Rejects Claims Free Nutritious Meals Programme Violates Human Rights, Accuses Komnas HAM of Bias
JAKARTA — The Human Rights Ministry has hit back at the National Human Rights Commission (Komnas HAM) over its claims of four human rights violations in the Free Nutritious Meals (MBG) programme. The ministry disagrees that human rights violations have occurred in the programme’s implementation.
Munafrizal Manan, the ministry’s director-general for Human Rights Services and Compliance, accused Komnas HAM of bias in concluding that the MBG programme violated human rights. From a human rights perspective, he said, MBG falls within the sphere of economic, social and cultural (ESC) rights. A number of countries run meal programmes as a means of fulfilling ESC rights, particularly the right to food.
Under international human rights instruments, the fulfilment of ESC rights is based on the principle of progressive realisation: human rights may be fulfilled progressively. This principle recognises that countries do not all have the same capacity to fulfil ESC rights, and that their fulfilment requires active involvement by the state.
“A country’s inability or fiscal constraints are often used as reasons not to fulfil ESC rights,” Munafrizal said on Saturday (10 November 2026).
Under the principle of progressive realisation, Munafrizal said, the state must not neglect or evade its duty to fulfil ESC rights, even though countries have differing capacities. Each country is required to make a good-faith effort to fulfil those rights, with implementation adjusted to its capacity.
Munafrizal stressed that this principle means the fulfilment of ESC rights can vary from country to country, depending on each country’s circumstances and capabilities, as well as the problems and challenges it faces.
“It is not right to conclude that a human rights violation has occurred whenever there are developments in the implementation of measures to fulfil ESC rights. The way human rights violations are assessed for ESC rights differs from the way they are assessed for civil and political rights. From the perspective of ESC rights, a violation occurs when the state does nothing to fulfil them,” Munafrizal said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/government-rejects-claims-free-nutritious-meals-programme-violates-human-rights-accuses-komnas-ham-of-bias-1791633033)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tmotzg409/pemerintah-tak-terima-mbg-dinilai-langgar-ham-tuding-komnas-ham-tendensius), translated from Indonesian