Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Government Expert: Presidential Insult Article Not a Threat to Free Expression

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Government Expert: Presidential Insult Article Not a Threat to Free Expression
Image: CNN Indonesia

An expert presented by Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto has asserted that the clause concerning attacks on the honour of the President in Law 1/2023 regarding the Criminal Code (KUHP) does not constitute a threat to freedom of expression.

This was stated by the expert during a follow-up judicial review hearing at the Constitutional Court (MK) in Jakarta on Tuesday (9/6). The court is reviewing several petitions, including Petition Numbers 2/PUU-XXIII/2025, 280/PUU-XXIII/2025, and others, challenging the legality of the new penal code.

Criminal law expert Albert Aries, called by the President, addressed the court’s concerns regarding allegations that the regulation criminalises critics of the ruling power. He noted that one issue to be clarified in this judicial review is whether the ‘chilling effect’—the fear that Article 218 of the KUHP will criminalise criticism or threaten freedom of opinion—is valid, especially since no complaints have been filed since the law’s scheduled implementation on 2 January 2026.

According to Aries, the explanation within Article 218 of the KUHP clarifies that criticism involving disagreement with the policies or actions of the President and/or Vice President is not a criminal offence. Simply put, unlawful acts punishable under Article 218 are those that attack the honour or dignity of the President or Vice President through acts that demean or damage their reputation, such as insults or slander.

He further explained the use of the term ‘person’ (diri) in the article, noting that while the object of the offence is similar to existing defamation laws, the legal construction is distinct. He noted that the subjectivity of the insulted party can be tested against the objectivity of the act, allowing individuals to prove the truth of their allegations under Article 434 of the new KUHP.

Regarding the legal structure, Aries clarified that Article 218 of the new KUHP is an absolute complaint-based offence (delik aduan absolut). This means that even if someone insults or slanders the President or Vice President, no legal process will occur unless the President or Vice President personally files a complaint. He added that the President is under no obligation to exercise this right, citing the Latin maxim ‘juro suo ut ut nemo cogitur’ (no one is compelled to use their right).

Furthermore, under Article 218, paragraph 2 of the new KUHP, an act does not constitute an attack on honour if it is performed for the public interest or in self-defence. Aries noted that the law clearly distinguishes between ‘criticism’ and ‘offence’ (slander or libel), aligning with Article 19(3) of the ICCPR, which Indonesia ratified via Law Number 12 of 2005, allowing for limitations on expression to respect the rights of others and protect public order.

He concluded that if the President or Vice President chooses to file a complaint, investigators and prosecutors will proceed, but the Supreme Court remains the ultimate judicial authority to assess whether the act constitutes an insult and to evaluate grounds for criminal immunity.

The lawsuit against the presidential honour clause was filed by several civil parties, including students. The petitioners are challenging Articles 218 (paragraphs 1 and 2), 219, and 220 of Law 1/2023, arguing that these provisions violate the Indonesian Constitution, specifically regarding guarantees of freedom of expression, equality before the law, and legal certainty. The petitioners argue that the provisions create a ‘fear effect’ in society, discouraging citizens from expressing criticism in the public sphere.

More from 9 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/government-expert-presidential-insult-article-not-a-threat-to-free-expression-1781013509)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260609145429-12-1367104/ahli-pemerintah-pasal-hina-presiden-bukan-ancaman-kebebasan-ekspresi), translated from Indonesian
Print