Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Government and DPR Urged to Focus on Local Democracy Quality After Constitutional Court Ruling

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Government and DPR Urged to Focus on Local Democracy Quality After Constitutional Court Ruling
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Jakarta (ANTARA) - Arfianto Purbolaksono, a Research Associate at The Indonesian Institute (TII), stated that the government and the House of Representatives (DPR) need to focus on reforming the quality of local democracy following the Constitutional Court (MK) ruling regarding regional elections (pilkada).

According to him, ruling number 1s5/PUU-XXIV/2026 provides legal certainty amidst growing discourse regarding changing the regional election mechanism to being selected through Regional House of Representatives (DPRD), which has been developing in recent times.

“The Court affirms that the current system is an implementation of the principle of people’s sovereignty, as emphasised in various previous rulings of the Court,” he said in a written statement in Jakarta on Wednesday.

In addition to providing legal certainty, he noted that the ruling also reinforces that the strengthening of local democracy must be achieved through the improvement of election governance, rather than by reducing the space for public participation in determining their leaders.

Arfianto stated that the ruling, delivered on Monday (29/6), aligns with the results of a TII study titled Policy Assessment 2026, which shows that the majority of the Indonesian people still desire regional heads to be elected directly.

The study, he noted, also found that the legitimacy of regional heads is determined not only by aspects of constitutional legality but also by public acceptance of a democratic process that provides space for direct participation.

Furthermore, he argued that arguments linking direct regional elections to high political costs and corruption need to be viewed more comprehensively.

“Historical experience shows that money politics also occurs when regional heads are elected through the DPRD, even with a more closed political transaction space among the elite,” he said.

Therefore, he believes the Constitutional Court ruling should serve as a turning point for the government and Parliament to shift focus from debates regarding the election mechanism towards improving the quality of implementation.

“The future Election Bill needs to be directed towards strengthening election supervision, transparency in political financing, law enforcement against money politics, increasing the capacity of election organisers, and public political education so that the quality of local democracy continues to improve,” said Arimentho.

Previously, the Constitutional Court stated that the judicial review petition regarding Article 1, point 1 of Law Number 8 of 2015 concerning the Election of Governors, Regents, and Mayors (Regional Election Law) could not be accepted.

This article stipulates that the election of regional heads is an implementation of people’s sovereignty in provinces and regencies/cities to elect governors and vice governors, regents and vice regents, as well as mayors and vice mayors directly and democratically.

In their petition, four students named Vendy Setiawan, Lala Komalawati, Susi Lestari, and Afifah Nabila Putri questioned the phrase “directly” in the said article.

According to the petitioners, the article is open to multiple interpretations because there is no certain norm limiting that the phrase “directly” must be interpreted as “by the people” through voting. Therefore, they requested confirmation that regional elections are conducted directly by the people.

In its legal considerations, the Constitutional Court found no actual or potential loss of constitutional rights as alleged by the petitioners.

According to the Court, the petitioners’ concerns regarding the possibility of future changes in legal policy, political discourse, and academic anxiety are not a direct consequence of the enforcement of Article 1, point 1 of the Regional Election Law.

This is because, according to the Court, to date, regional elections are still conducted directly by the people.

“The mechanism for electing regional heads to date is carried out directly by the people, guided by the election principles that apply generally, while still recognising and respecting local government units that are special or extraordinary,” stated the Court’s consideration.

More from 1 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/government-and-dpr-urged-to-focus-on-local-democracy-quality-after-constitutional-court-ruling-1782903341)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5630623/pemerintah-dpr-diminta-fokus-kualitas-demokrasi-lokal-pascaputusan-mk), translated from Indonesian
Print