GOTO's Exit from MSCI Index Sounds Alarm on Indonesian Capital Market Quality
The removal of PT GoTo Gojek Tokopedia Tbk (GOTO) from the MSCI Global Standard Indexes and the demotion of PT Charoen Pokphand Indonesia Tbk (CPIN) to the MSCI Small Cap Indexes are being seen as a serious signal for the Indonesian capital market. These changes are considered not just routine rotations, but an alarm regarding the quality of liquidity and investability of issuers in the eyes of global investors.
Capital market analyst and Founder of Republik Investor, Hendra Wardana, asserted that MSCI’s decision indicates the challenges facing Indonesia’s capital market have now shifted. The main issue is no longer solely about market capitalisation size or the quantity of issuers, but has touched on the fundamental aspects of accessibility for institutional investors.
“This is an alarm that the problem with the Indonesian capital market is no longer just about the number of issuers or market capitalisation, but has touched on the quality of liquidity and investability,” Hendra told Media Indonesia on Thursday.
According to Hendra, MSCI applies strict parameters in determining its index constituents. When a stock no longer meets the standards for investable market cap and daily liquidity, a downgrade or removal is a logical consequence. This situation is ironic amidst the regulator’s efforts to enhance shareholder transparency, increase free float, and strengthen corporate governance.
Hendra assessed that GOTO’s large market capitalisation did not necessarily guarantee strong investability if it was not accompanied by the ease of transacting in large volumes without disrupting price stability. The impact of these index changes cannot be underestimated. Institutional investors and passive fund managers who use MSCI as a benchmark will certainly adjust their portfolios. This has the potential to trigger selling pressure, especially if liquidity in the regular market is thin.
Amid a significant trend of net selling by foreign investors throughout the year, the exit of major issuers from global indices is feared to worsen market perception. Global investors are predicted to become even more selective in placing their funds in Indonesia. Hendra stressed that the cases of GOTO and CPIN must be seen as a momentum for a comprehensive evaluation of the national capital market ecosystem. Adding more issuers and new products is important, but growth in demand and liquidity is far more crucial.
“The capital market does not only need many stocks, but stocks that are actively traded, have a healthy free float, and are supported by credible governance capable of absorbing large-scale institutional investor transactions,” he added. Regulators and the Indonesia Stock Exchange are urged not to view liquidity merely as a technical trading issue, but as an indicator of market quality. Capital market reform must go beyond administrative improvements to ensure the Indonesian market remains attractive, transparent, and accessible to the global investment community.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/gotos-exit-from-msci-index-sounds-alarm-on-indonesian-capital-market-quality-1786593020)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/ekonomi/921311/goto-keluar-dari-indeks-msci-alarm-kualitas-pasar-modal-indonesia), translated from Indonesian