Google’s Money-Making Engine Stalls as Instagram Reaps AI Windfall
Two internet giants that have profited from global advertising spending for two decades are now heading in opposite directions. AI is boosting Meta’s advertising revenue, while Google’s source of income, Search, is coming under pressure. The divergence has sent shockwaves through the stock market.
In the third quarter this year, Meta’s advertising revenue rose 26% to US$63.1 billion, or about Rp1,104 trillion. Google’s search division, meanwhile, grew by just 12%, half Meta’s rate, with revenue of US$63.4 billion. The 14-percentage-point growth gap in Meta’s favour is the widest since 2021.
For Google, the figures triggered alarm. Shares in its parent company, Alphabet, plunged by more than 12% after the earnings report was released, wiping out around US$500 billion, or Rp8,750 trillion, in market value in a single day—the company’s biggest-ever decline.
The reason lies in how each company is using artificial intelligence.
Meta has built AI directly into its advertising engine. AI assistants help design campaigns, target the most suitable users and suggest improvements to make adverts more effective. Advertisers using these features have recorded an increase of nearly 5% in conversions and a 9% rise in advertising spend. For example, maple syrup producer Simply Organic Maple saw sales increase by 57% while its cost per purchase fell by 36%. Nearly 10 million advertisers now use these AI tools.
Google, by contrast, is in a difficult position. AI products such as ChatGPT, Claude and Google’s own Gemini are encouraging users to find answers directly, without clicking on links. Each click on a link is a potential source of advertising revenue. The better AI gets at answering questions, the fewer people visit websites through search—and the fewer adverts they see.
A new competitor has also emerged from Meta, which recently launched an AI assistant called Muse.
“This is a double-edged sword. If people can find the answers they are looking for without having to click on anything, search engines lose their main reason for being visited,” Nate Elliott, an analyst at Emarketer, told CNBC International. “This change in behaviour could be disastrous for Google’s advertising business.”
Google has incorporated AI into its advertising system, but the impact has yet to become apparent. Meanwhile, its AI Overview feature, which displays answer summaries directly on search pages, is accelerating the decline in clicks. Google says searches have reached a record high, but revenue is growing much more slowly.
Both companies are spending extraordinary sums to build AI infrastructure. Google plans capital expenditure of up to US$205 billion this year, while Meta has earmarked US$145 billion. Neither has yet secured returns on a comparable scale.
Their differing business profiles add to the pressure. Advertising accounts for 98% of Meta’s revenue, so any improvement has an immediate impact. Google is more diversified, with advertising now representing less than two-thirds of its total revenue, but Search remains its biggest money-maker. If Google Search growth slows, the whole company will feel the strain.
Both companies are now trying to find a way forward. Meta has begun developing subscription revenue so it does not rely entirely on advertising.
Google is accelerating growth in its cloud services business, which rose by more than 100% this quarter to US$31 billion. But so far, nothing has been able to replace the cash-generating power of Search.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/googles-money-making-engine-stalls-as-instagram-reaps-ai-windfall-1793595074)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/tech/20261102100630-37-781424/sumber-duit-google-makin-seret-ketika-instagram-panen-cuan-ai), translated from Indonesian