Golkar Legislator on 'National Constituency': Interesting, but Do Not Cause Confusion
Ahmad Irawan, a member of Commission II of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI) from the Golkar Faction, has responded to the Democratic Party’s proposal regarding the concept of a ‘National Constituency’ or ‘national pool’ for the election of DPR RI members. He stated that while the proposal is interesting, it must be further matured.
“The concept of a national constituency (national pool) or the pooling of votes (stembus accord) is an interesting idea. Any idea must be matured and tested so that it can be implemented effectively,” said Ahmad Irawan when contacted on Wednesday (23/9/2026).
He stated that his party would review the matter, adding that as long as any idea aligns with the principles of constitutional democracy, the Golkar Party will support it.
He also touched upon electoral practices in various countries around the world. However, he warned that such a system should not create new problems or lead to voter confusion.
“The advantage of a national pool, taking the example of Germany as mentioned by Mr Dede Yusuf, is that the candidates receiving the people’s mandate are determined by political parties. This could strengthen party institutions. Many long-serving party officials or activists with high competence often lose under the expensive open proportional system,” he said.
In his view, electoral systems in other countries, such as Germany, are worth testing in Indonesia. However, he emphasised the need for in-depth study before implementation to prevent public confusion.
“We have had our own electoral systems and practices through several elections. Looking at other countries is good within the framework of system refinement. But again, we must study and mature it so it can be implemented, rather than creating new problems or confusing the people and making election administration increasingly complex,” he explained.
Previously, the Deputy Chairman of the Democratic Party, Dede Yusuf, responded to NasDem Party Chairman Surya Paloh’s consistent proposal for a parliamentary threshold of 7 per cent. The Democratic Party subsequently raised concerns regarding the millions of votes wasted under the 4 per cent parliamentary threshold applied in the previous election.
“The Democratic Party is currently studying this, and it is not about the percentage. It is about how many people’s votes will be wasted if the concept remains a fixed percentage threshold. Previously, with only 4 per cent, up to 17 million votes were wasted. In 2009, with a 2.5 per cent threshold, 19 million votes were wasted,” Dede began his opinion on Sunday (20/9).
Dede stated that the Democratic Party is proposing the ‘National Constituency’ or ‘national pool’ concept for the election of DPR RI members. He emphasised that the remaining votes from parties that pass the threshold could be pooled and then used to determine additional seats in the DPR.
Dede also referenced the pooling of remaining votes (stembus accord) used in the 1999 Election. He expressed hope that studying this concept could reduce the number of wasted votes.
“That is why the Democratic Party has proposed the ‘National Constituency’ (national pool) concept from the beginning. The remaining votes from parties that pass the threshold would be converted into a national constituency so that no people’s votes are wasted. The ‘stembus accord’ model was used in the past,” Dede said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/golkar-legislator-on-national-constituency-interesting-but-do-not-cause-confusion-1790125055)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8674913/legislator-golkar-soal-dapil-nasional-menarik-tapi-jangan-bikin-bingung), translated from Indonesian