Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Golkar faces huge challenges

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Golkar faces huge challenges

By Aleksius Jemadu

BANDUNG (JP): Election campaigns can be viewed as a process of
linking the agenda of the politicians and the aspirations of the
people.

The three election contestants, the dominant Golkar
organization, the United Development Party (PPP), and the
Indonesian Democratic Party (PDI), should prepare their
respective political agendas in order to gain legitimacy from the
people.

Through their campaigns the contestants will try to convince
the people that they would best represent their interests in the
legislative body.

The list of candidates for members of the House of
Representatives from each political party has been publicized but
people still need to know more about the contestants differing
development agendas.

The 1997 election has a special strategic meaning for
Indonesia as it will produce leaders who will have to prepare the
country to enter the 21st century. Professionalism and patriotism
are the essential qualifications they should have in order to
deal with the challenges ahead. On top of that, the
institutionalization of the political parties as modern and
democratic organizations is a necessity.

The main purpose of this article is to analyze the constraints
and opportunities faced by Golkar in attracting the sympathy and
support of the people, by referring to both its internal and
external environment. Both the strengths and weaknesses of the
political party will be identified.

It is obvious that the main challenge for Golkar in the
election is to maintain its position as the dominant party. There
are several elements that need to be considered when we analyze
the internal environment of a political party. The first variable
is concerned with the level of integration among its
constituents.

A political party has a high level of integration if it has
the capacity to overcome internal rivalries and to accommodate
its constituents' pluralistic aspirations.

Golkar is the product of an amalgamation of different
political groups with different historical backgrounds and
political orientations. It represents a coalition between the
army and technocrats who are more concerned with economic
development than ideological antagonism.

The name, Golkar or Golongan Karya, literally means the
functional groups. It indicates a heavy emphasis on real action
or work (karya).

The second variable is the quality of the leadership. Of
particular importance in this regard is the extent to which
political leaders can develop independent leadership free from
external pressures. Effective leadership normally emerges out of
a real commitment to the cause of the party and in turn generates
popular support within the party.

The third internal variable has more to do with the capacity
of each contestant to offer sensible development programs which
are progressive enough to deal with the present bottlenecks in
the distribution of development resources.

The success of a contestant in conducting campaign activities
depends to a great extent on its financial resources. With ample
resources a contestant can choose how to take its message to the
people. The use of electronic media is particularly preferable to
ensure nationwide coverage and to reach the minds of the people
through the manipulation of audiovisual communication.

The external environment refers to the general attitude of the
public toward the three political parties. It is not easy to make
a convincing assessment on this variable and we can only make an
educated guess.

Subjective as it might be, such guesses can be very important
to ascertain the contestants' election prospects. This variable
is very much linked to the core values of the political parties.
Even though Golkar, PPP, and PDI all accept Pancasila as their
sole ideology, each of them does have unique characteristics,
especially with regard to their historical background. The
regulations and rules of the game during the campaign can be
considered an important element in the external environment.

Based on the analysis of the internal and external environment
of the political parties, we can make an assessment regarding the
likely configuration of political power among the contestants.

Golkar is highly integrated. There is currently no indication
of any significant internal rivalry which could threaten its
unity.

Some observers might suggest that there is a possibility of
conflict between the military and civil leaders as happened in
the past. Yet the role of President Soeharto as chairman of the
grouping's supervisory council is strong enough to prevent any
seeds of disintegration from growing. There is a kind of
balancing mechanism which thus far has succeeded in managing
Golkar's potential internal conflicts.

In addition, Golkar has learned from past experience how to
accommodate the pluralistic interests of its constituents.
However, it remains to be seen how long Golkar can sustain its
integrity.

As the autonomy of Golkar as a political organization is as
questionable as it was in the sixties and seventies, can it
survive without the strong support of the government and the
army? What is actually the "inner being" of this organization?

If economic development can be said to be its specific
mission, what is the basis to believe that the other two parties
cannot carry out the same mission? Isn't it only a matter of
opportunity? How could Golkar maintain unity among its
pluralistic constituents without the intervention of its senior
leaders? Or is it that paternalistic leadership is indispensable
to its survival? These are critical questions that have to be
dealt with if Golkar wants to ensure its legitimacy and supremacy
as the dominant political organization.

The second challenge for Golkar is the quality of its
leadership. The presence of an independent leader is one of the
basic characteristics a modern organization should have.

Modern political parties have no indispensable figures,
implying that existence is not dependent on the identity of the
leader. Another element of strong leadership relates to the
leaders' relationship with its members.

It is a common phenomenon in developing countries that the
ruling party always faces a dilemma in choosing a leader. On one
hand the party has to accommodate the interests of the political
system as a whole and on the other hand there is constant
pressure to articulate the interests of its own members.

Failure to meet the first condition is usually too risky for
any ruling party as it relies heavily on government support to
survive. But to ignore the rising expectations of its members is
to destroy its own legitimacy. There seems to be no easy choice
for the ruling party in reconciling the two necessities.

During the election campaign Golkar's campaigners will have to
convince the public that as a political organization Golkar has
the capacity to cope with the ever changing aspirations of the
people. Golkar should be able to convince the public that it is
not just a machine of the ruling elite there to win the elections
and provide the regime's required legitimacy.

Golkar may identify itself with the success of the New Order
government in sustaining the economic growth over the last three
decades. It is almost certain that Golkar's campaigners will use
this issue to convince the people that if they want economic
development to continue they must back Golkar.

Thus, Golkar will try to capitalize on the performance of the
New Order government to increase its political standing vis a vis
the other two contenders. It should not be a surprise then that
Golkar has used ministers and other senior government officials
as vote getters.

However, identification with the success of the ruling power
can also be a political liability. It is almost expected that in
the eyes of the people Golkar should also be held responsible for
the shortcomings of the government. Hot issues like the widening
gap between the rich and the poor, nepotism, collusion, human
rights, overcentralization of power, can be used by the other
contestants to attack Golkar.

Many would suggest that the best way to deal with such
criticism is to be honest and humble before the people while
explaining that compared to other developing countries Indonesia
still rates better as far as the eradication of poverty and the
maintenance of political stability are concerned.

It seems that Golkar has no objection to the government's
campaign rules and regulations. It is even argued that the rules
greatly benefit the dominant organization and hinder the other
contestants.

However, Golkar has to be careful in using these rules for its
own purposes. The principles of honesty and justice should be
manifested in campaign activities, otherwise people will get
disappointed and turn their attention to the "disadvantaged" two,
PPP and PDI.

Golkar has ample resources to maintain its supremacy over the
other two contestants but the attitude of its leaders and
campaigners will eventually determine how effectively the
organization will use its resources to win the election.

The writer is a lecturer in the Faculty of Social and
Political Sciences at the Catholic University of Parahyangan,
Bandung. He obtained his Ph.D in social sciences from KU Leuven,
Belgium.

Window: Modern political parties have no indispensable figures,
implying that existence is not dependent on the identity of the
leader.

More from 25 March 1997 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/golkar-faces-huge-challenges-1447893297-1526274)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print