Goldman Sachs: Indonesia Risks Losing Rp100 Trillion in Funds over MSCI
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia — Goldman Sachs says Indonesia must prove that its announced capital-market reforms are being consistently implemented and are improving market functioning if it is to avoid a downgrade by Morgan Stanley Capital International (MSCI). The assessment was set out in a Goldman Sachs report dated 18 October 2026.
On 16 October, MSCI proposed reclassifying Indonesia directly from emerging market to standalone market. Feedback on the consultation is open until 30 April 2027, with a final decision due no later than 30 June 2027. If MSCI proceeds, implementation could begin as early as the August 2027 Quarterly Index Review, Goldman said.
“If MSCI proceeds with the proposal, implementation could begin as early as the August 2027 Quarterly Index Review. This marks a significant escalation from the review in June,” Goldman wrote in its research report, cited on Thursday (22 October 2026).
Goldman described MSCI’s move as an escalation from its June market-classification review. MSCI now considers Indonesia’s emerging-market status no longer appropriate, shifting the burden of proof to Indonesia.
To retain its status, Indonesia must provide clear evidence that reforms are being implemented consistently and are improving market functioning.
“To retain Emerging Market status, Indonesia must show clear evidence that the reforms announced are genuinely being implemented consistently and are bringing significant improvements to market functioning,” Goldman wrote.
According to Goldman, the areas under scrutiny include opaque share-ownership structures, suspected coordinated trading and weak law enforcement. MSCI is said to “expect to proceed” with the proposal unless the consultation finds evidence of material improvements in governance and market functioning.
“This primarily includes resolving issues around opaque share-ownership structures, suspected coordinated trading activity and weak enforcement of the rules,” Goldman said.
Goldman also said MSCI had cited feedback from market participants who felt that frontier status would not adequately reflect the depth of the problems, prompting the proposal to move directly to standalone status. Standalone status would be more damaging because Indonesia would be removed from major composite indices without an equivalent replacement index.
During the consultation period, Indonesia will remain in MSCI’s emerging-market indices, so the announcement will not trigger immediate passive selling. However, Goldman said additions of stocks and increases in index weights would remain suspended, while MSCI could still reduce free-float estimates and take action against stocks with highly concentrated ownership.
“As a result, index changes during the consultation period are likely to point towards stability or further declines,” Goldman said.
If Indonesia is ultimately removed from MSCI indices, Goldman estimates that passive funds could withdraw about US$5.6 billion, or Rp100.8 trillion at an exchange rate of Rp18,000 to the US dollar. This is equivalent to 18 days of average trading volume in the constituents of the MSCI Indonesia IMI. The figure could rise by around US$2.7 billion if FTSE Russell followed suit. Goldman noted that FTSE Russell still classifies Indonesia as a secondary emerging market and has not placed it on a watch list, so this is considered a separate scenario.
Active funds benchmarked against MSCI or FTSE indices hold more than US$8 billion in Indonesian shares. However, Goldman said any selling by active funds would be discretionary rather than automatically triggered by index rules.
“Active funds that use these indices (MSCI and FTSE) as benchmarks hold more than US$8 billion in additional assets; nevertheless, any potential selling would be discretionary, based on fund managers’ decisions, and not driven by benchmark rules,” it said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/goldman-sachs-indonesia-risks-losing-rp100-trillion-in-funds-over-msci-1792644672)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/market/20261022100054-17-778486/goldman-sachs-ri-terancam-kehilangan-dana-rp100-triliun-gegara-msci), translated from Indonesian