Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Global Wars Trigger Calls for UN Reform, Questioning Dominance of Five Nations

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Global Wars Trigger Calls for UN Reform, Questioning Dominance of Five Nations
Image: Republika

Waves of widespread war and conflict across various regions have reopened long-standing debates concerning the power structure of the United as Nations (UN). From the podium of the UN General Assembly in New York, several world leaders have questioned whether the five nations holding veto power in the Security Council are still appropriate to wield such significant influence over decisions affecting 193 member states.

The United States, Russia, China, the United Kingdom, and France have served as the five permanent members, or P5, of the Security Council since the international order was established following World War II. Eight decades later, numerous countries believe this structure no longer reflects the world’s demographic, economic, and geopolitical shifts.

The debate has intensified as the UN faces wars in Iran, Gaza, Ukraine, Sudan, Congo, and Myanmar. The Associated Press (AP) noted that the international body’s ability to end major conflicts is being questioned once again at this year’s 81st General Assembly.

UN Secretary-General António Guterres even reminded world leaders that military force alone cannot produce peace. In his final speech as Secretary-General at the General Assembly, he warned that the world’s lines of division are widening.

Guterres will conclude his second term on 31 December 2026. His departure coincides with the strengthening of a much more fundamental question: not only who will next lead the UN, but also how capable this 81-year-old organisation remains of fulfilling its mandate.

The World is Larger Than Five

One of the harshest criticisms came from Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. In his speech to the General Assembly on Tuesday (22/9/2026), Erdoğan stated that a system that makes the will of more than 190 countries dependent on five nations cannot be considered fair.

“Let us admit that a system where the will of more than 190 countries is subject to five countries is not a fair system,” Erdoğan said, as reported by Reuters.

For years, Erdoğan has campaigned under the slogan that “the world is larger than five.” According to him, the composition of the Security Council must be more inclusive and reflect the current configuration of the international community, rather than the balance of power present when the UN was founded after World as II.

He stated that the UN, established 81 years ago to maintain world peace and security, is now unable to fully perform that duty. This call for reform resurfaced as wars in several regions became the primary agenda for world leaders meeting in New York.

The issue is not merely the number of countries sitting on the Security Council. The five permanent members possess veto power, which allows a single nation to block a resolution even if it has broad support from other members.

For countries demanding reform, this structure makes decisions regarding war and peace overly dependent on the interests of great powers. However, the idea of abolishing the veto power faces opposition from at least one of the P5 nations.

Russia Agrees to Reform, Veto to be Retained

Russia responded directly to Erdoğan’s call. The Kremlin stated it supports the expansion of permanent members of the Security Council but rejects the abolition of the veto power.

Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said Russia considers the Security Council in need of reform and that the number of permanent members could be expanded. However, Moscow views the status of permanent members and the veto power as essential elements of the UN structure.

“The institution of permanent members of the Security Council, as well as the veto power, are very important elements,” said Peskov.

This position highlights one of the primary obstacles to UN reform. Even when there is agreement on the need for change, nations do not always agree on the nature of that change.

Some desire the addition of seats for countries that have historically lacked permanent representation, while others wish to address the more fundamental issue: the veto power that grants special authority to the five nations.

More from 24 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/global-wars-trigger-calls-for-un-reform-questioning-dominance-of-five-nations-1790202049)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tltqyb451/perang-global-picu-desakan-reformasi-pbb-dominasi-5-negara-dipersoalkan), translated from Indonesian
Print