Global Oil Prices Defy Logic: Is China Playing a Part?
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia – Middle Eastern oil exports have begun to recover after months of disruption caused by the war with Iran. Yet global oil prices have continued to climb, returning close to the highs reached last April.
Vortexa data show that Middle Eastern oil exports exceeded 17 million barrels per day in the week to 23 October 2026. That was only about 4 million barrels per day below the level in 2025.
Despite the increase in supply, Brent crude has surged by around 20% since early September, reaching US$115 a barrel.
Meanwhile, global oil inventories remain far below pre-war levels. The International Energy Agency (IEA) reported that monitored global oil stocks had fallen by 509 million barrels by the end of September compared with the end of February 2026. Onshore stocks are at their lowest level in a decade.
Three factors are keeping prices high despite the recovery in Middle Eastern exports: increased Chinese oil purchases, higher shipping costs and fears that the war could intensify again.
China is buying oil again
China is one reason why the additional supply has not been enough to bring prices down.
In March 2026, the Chinese government banned exports of refined oil products to safeguard domestic supplies during the war with Iran. Refineries drew on existing stocks, while fuel consumption also declined.
As a result, China’s crude oil imports fell by almost half, or around 6 million barrels per day, between February and June.
The drop in imports helped contain the rise in global oil prices. As supplies from the Middle East were disrupted, demand from China was also weakening.
The situation began to change in June. Easing tensions between Iran and the United States brought oil prices down, while refinery margins in several countries reached record highs.
This happened while oil exports from the Gulf remained constrained and Ukrainian attacks continued to target Russian refineries. Chinese refineries pressed the government to allow exports of refined products again.
From July, China resumed exports of refined products and increased its crude oil imports.
In the three weeks to 16 October, Chinese oil imports had risen by more than 3 million barrels per day compared with June.
Neil Crosby of FGE NexantECA said the increase was large enough to absorb some of the additional Middle Eastern oil exports.
So, as oil supplies began to recover, Chinese demand also picked up. Although Chinese purchases have eased slightly more recently, the earlier surge has helped keep prices high.
Oil shipping costs are rising
Oil prices have also been pushed up by higher shipping costs. One of the causes is the way China buys oil.
Rather than buying according to a set schedule, China is increasingly seeking bargains on the spot market. Tom Reed of Argus Media said this makes demand for tankers difficult to predict, pushing up charter costs.
At the same time, growing oil exports from the Gulf through the Strait of Hormuz have increased the need for tankers.
Shipping oil along this route has also become more complicated. State-owned tankers have to pass through the Strait of Hormuz covertly to collect oil, then transfer their cargo to other vessels in the Gulf of Oman.
The receiving vessels can wait for days before taking on cargo. As a result, more ships are tied up transporting oil, leaving fewer vessels available.
Freight costs have risen sharply. Previously, shipping accounted for around 4% to 7% of the cost of oil delivered to Chinese buyers. In October, that share rose to 25% to 30%.
The impact is also being felt in oil prices across different regions.
Producers in Latin America and West Africa have had to offer discounts to remain competitive because they are farther from buyers. By contrast, North Sea producers have been able to maintain higher prices.
The price gap between the cheapest and most expensive grades of oil at one point approached US$60 a barrel. This difference has also contributed to the rise in Brent prices.
The threat of war still hangs over the market
However, Chinese demand and higher shipping costs do not fully explain the high price of oil.
JPMorgan Chase estimates that Brent is currently about US$20 a barrel above its fair value. The gap primarily reflects market fears that a renewed conflict could again disrupt Middle Eastern oil supplies.
Iran reportedly attacked at least 30 ships in October, the highest monthly total since the war began.
Yemen’s Houthi group has also attacked several cities, airports, oil refineries and Saudi Arabia’s East-West pipeline, which had only recently been repaired.
The conflict’s influence on oil prices can be seen in Brent’s movements during October.
Morgan Stanley’s calculations show that, in the month to 22 October, Brent moved by more than US$2.50 a barrel on eight days. On seven of those days, the movements coincided with reports of peace talks or escalating tensions.
The market is also waiting to see what US President Donald Trump will do after he signalled that new strikes against Iran could follow the US midterm elections on 3 November.
Amid this uncertainty, relatively low trading volumes in Brent futures have made oil prices more sensitive to investor speculation. Buying by market participants who expect prices to rise can also trigger larger price swings.
If Trump does not resume attacks, oil prices could fall within days.
Conversely, if the US launches another major offensive, accompanied by attacks from Iran and the Houthis, Brent could climb to US$130–140 a barrel, according to Jim Burkhard of S&P Global.
Even so, China still has substantial oil stocks, while developed countries hold strategic reserves that could be used if prices surge again.
For now, the market does not appear to expect supply disruptions to end soon. Prices for Brent futures, refinery margins and shipping costs for future periods indicate that the risks are being factored in through 2027.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/global-oil-prices-defy-logic-is-china-playing-a-part-1793350311)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/research/20261030112030-128-780954/harga-minyak-dunia-tak-masuk-akal-ada-permainan-china), translated from Indonesian