Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Gibran’s Lawyer Says Ruling on High School Equivalency Certificate Will Not Affect Vice-President’s Position

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Gibran’s Lawyer Says Ruling on High School Equivalency Certificate Will Not Affect Vice-President’s Position
Image: detikcom

Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s lawyer, Muhammad Rullyandi, said the Supreme Court’s decision granting a petition to revoke the validity of Gibran’s high school education equivalency certificate would not affect his client’s position as Vice-President. He argued that the ruling could not be fully enforced because the legal situation had changed before it was issued.

“I believe the Supreme Court ruling granting the petition to revoke the validity of Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s high school education equivalency certificate, which was an administrative requirement for his candidacy as Vice-President in the 2024 election, does not affect Gibran’s position as Vice-President,” Rullyandi told reporters on Saturday (31 October 2026).

“The reason is that the Supreme Court ruling cannot be properly enforced because a prior legal situation has arisen,” he added.

He explained that the Supreme Court issued its decision after all stages of the 2024 presidential election had concluded and Gibran had been formally sworn in as Vice-President. He therefore maintained that the ruling could not be applied retrospectively.

“The Supreme Court ruling meets the relevant criteria under administrative court procedure, with reference to Article 117, paragraph 1, of Law No. 5/1986. In essence, a ruling that cannot be properly enforced cannot be carried out because a prior legal situation has arisen,” he said.

He said the equivalency certificate had been used to meet the administrative requirements for candidacy during the 2024 election, which has now concluded. In his view, although the Supreme Court’s decision is legally binding, it cannot be enforced.

“Although the Supreme Court ruling is legally binding, it cannot be fully enforced; it is non-executable and cannot be used as a basis for enforcement in connection with political efforts by the House of Representatives to pursue impeachment,” he said.

“Moreover, an extraordinary legal remedy remains available through a judicial review, which the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education, as the defendant, may pursue,” he added.

Rullyandi further said proceedings were still under way at the Jakarta Administrative Court, despite the plaintiff having withdrawn the lawsuit and stopped attending hearings.

He said Gibran had been admitted as an intervening party in the case. In that capacity, Gibran had submitted evidence of his educational history, including certificates from primary, junior secondary and senior secondary school, as well as his bachelor’s degree.

“The Jakarta Administrative Court panel has set the next hearing agenda: the defendant’s reply and the submission of additional evidence by the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education,” he said.

The Supreme Court had earlier granted an appeal filed by a resident named Subhan concerning Gibran’s overseas high school equivalency certificate. The court ruled that the certificate was invalid and void by law.

“Appeal granted. The lower court ruling is set aside. The court rules on the merits: the plaintiff’s claim is granted in full,” said decision No. 742 K/TUN/2026, according to the Supreme Court’s official website on Friday (30 October).

Subhan filed the appeal in connection with his lawsuit at the Jakarta Administrative Court, case No. 62/G/2026/PTUN.JKT. The defendant was the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education. His claims were as follows:

  1. Grant the plaintiff’s claim in full.

  2. Declare Certificate No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, issued in Jakarta on 6 August 2019 by the Directorate General of Primary and Secondary Education, invalid and void by law.

  3. Order that the certificate be retrieved from whoever holds it and destroyed.

  4. Order the defendant to pay the legal costs.

The Jakarta Administrative Court initially rejected Subhan’s lawsuit. He then appealed, but the High Administrative Court upheld the Jakarta court’s decision. He subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court, which granted his claim.

Certificate No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019 is Gibran’s equivalency certificate for overseas high school education, which he used to register as a vice-presidential candidate in 2024. In a Constitutional Court ruling, the judges said they had found no evidence of Gibran’s overseas high school diploma on which the equivalency certificate was based.

More from 31 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/gibrans-lawyer-says-ruling-on-high-school-equivalency-certificate-will-not-affect-vice-presidents-position-1793433062)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8732384/kuasa-hukum-gibran-tegaskan-putusan-suket-sma-tak-pengaruhi-jabatan-wapres), translated from Indonesian
Print