Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Gibran’s High School Certificate Dispute Continues at Jakarta Administrative Court

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Gibran’s High School Certificate Dispute Continues at Jakarta Administrative Court
Image: detikcom

The issue of Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s high school qualification remains unresolved. Following a Constitutional Court (MK) ruling, the dispute over Gibran’s certificate is still being heard at the Jakarta Administrative Court (PTUN Jakarta).

The MK said it had found no evidence of a certificate from Gibran’s overseas school being used to obtain an equivalency letter for senior secondary education. It said the equivalency letter, which Gibran used as a requirement when registering as a vice-presidential candidate, had been issued on the basis of a certificate of attendance and documents other than a diploma.

However, the MK rejected a lawsuit seeking Gibran’s disqualification, ruling that the applicants had no legal standing to bring an election dispute.

The controversy over Gibran’s qualifications did not end with the MK ruling. A lawsuit challenging the issuance of the decision recognising the equivalency of Gibran’s education remains before PTUN Jakarta.

According to PTUN Jakarta’s Case Information System (SIPP), the lawsuit was registered under case number 255/G/2026/PTUN.JKT. The plaintiff is PT Mercy Toga Kirana, and the defendant is the Director General of Secondary and Special Education at the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education (Kemendikdasmen).

The plaintiff is asking the court to grant its claim in full; declare invalid Decision No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, dated 6 August 2019, on the equivalency of the certificate; and find that the decision is substantively defective because it was not based on primary documents, procedurally defective because it was issued by an unauthorised official and did not follow the required electronic format, and contrary to the principles of good governance, including diligence, transparency, legal certainty and equal treatment.

It also asks the court to order the defendant to revoke the decision in full and permanently and remove it from the state register within 60 working days of the ruling becoming final. The plaintiff further seeks an official, complete written response to its administrative clarification request of 11 February 2026 within 30 working days, as well as payment of all legal costs.

Several hearings have been held since August 2026. At the latest hearing, the agenda included the electronic submission of a response by the second intervening defendant and the presentation of additional documentary evidence by the plaintiff and defendant in person.

At the hearing, Denny Indrayana, counsel for the plaintiff, said his side had submitted a request to withdraw the lawsuit because the defendant had not produced the documents they considered necessary.

“For reasons unknown, the defendant has still not produced that evidence. In particular, as we recall from the Constitutional Court proceedings, there were three items we were asked to understand: first, the certificate of attendance at UTS Insearch; second, Mr Gibran’s transcript, given the account that he attended or took three different semesters of courses, which differs from the initial information for 2004–2007; and third, proof of enrolment. That is what we understood from the MK proceedings,” he said.

He said the documents should be held by Kemendikdasmen as the defendant, and that his side had been trying to obtain them since the MK hearings.

“These are highly substantive pieces of evidence for the defendant because the subject of our lawsuit is the equivalency letter. It is important to obtain the evidence on which that letter was based,” he said.

Denny said he felt he had not received justice because the documents had not been shown at the PTUN hearing, and cited this as the reason for withdrawing the lawsuit.

“Today, through the panel, we have submitted a letter withdrawing the lawsuit. What is the point if the defendant is unwilling to show the evidentiary basis for the letter, especially when that evidence has also been submitted to another court? We are protecting the dignity of the court,” he said.

The judge then invited Kemendikdasmen and Gibran’s representatives to state whether they accepted the withdrawal request. Gibran’s side objected.

“The defendant has said it respects these proceedings, but now, part-way through, it has submitted a request to withdraw the lawsuit. Given what has been presented, we object to the withdrawal,” a Kemendikdasmen representative said.

“Under procedural law, once a case has been examined, the defendant’s consent is required. We object to the plaintiff’s request to withdraw the lawsuit. This shows a lack of seriousness on the plaintiff’s part,” said Gibran’s lawyer, Muhammad Rullyandi.

Denny asked the judge for permission to leave the hearing, or walk out. The judge reminded Kemendikdasmen that the documents were important.

“We consider that they are all there. There is no reason not to submit them. When you do not submit the documents in question, what does that mean? It means there may be a document, procedure or substantive issue that is not in order or has been bypassed. This is the forum where you can maintain that trust,” the judge said.

Denny nevertheless left the courtroom and maintained his request to withdraw the lawsuit.

“While continuing to respect the honourable panel and these proceedings, I wish to reaffirm our position on the withdrawal. Although I understand what has just been read out, I ask permission to leave the courtroom,” Denny said as he walked out.

Gibran’s lawyer displays scanned certificates

Gibran’s lawyer, Muhammad Rullyandi, displayed scanned copies of Gibran’s certificates, from primary school through to his bachelor’s degree, to the judge in the courtroom.

He also showed the scans outside the courtroom. The documents included primary and junior secondary school certificates, a certificate of attendance from UTS Insearch, a diploma from the Management Development Institute of Singapore (MDIS), and a bachelor’s degree from the University of Bradford.

“We are ready to read out and show these documents to the panel of judges and our media colleagues as a demonstration of our openness to all Indonesians. We have included Mr Gibran Rakabuming’s educational history in our 69-page response. It is here, on page 50: his primary school certificate,” Rullyandi said.

Rullyandi said the scanned documents had been submitted to the judge and uploaded to the electronic court system.

“This response has been submitted to the panel, uploaded to the e-court system, and physical copies have also been provided to the plaintiff and the defendant,” he said.

He said the original certificates would also be submitted and shown in court.

“We will present all the originals later. Under procedural law, all originals must be submitted. That applies to the certificates; we will submit all the originals. We will show them at the appropriate time,” he said.

More from 30 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/gibrans-high-school-certificate-dispute-continues-at-jakarta-administrative-court-1793321510)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8730395/persoalan-terkait-ijazah-wapres-gibran-kini-bergulir-di-ptun), translated from Indonesian
Print