Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Gibran's Expert Files Complaint Against Constitutional Court Judges to Ethics Council

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Gibran's Expert Files Complaint Against Constitutional Court Judges to Ethics Council
Image: CNN Indonesia

Constitutional Law expert from Jayabaya University, Muhammad Rullyandi, has reported Constitutional Court Judges Saldi Isra and Arsul Sani to the Constitutional Court Ethics Council (MKMK).

He claims to have faced discrimination when requested to leave the courtroom during the hearing for case number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026 regarding the 2024 Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election dispute on Thursday (1/10) night. Rullyandi, acting as an expert for the ‘Perkumpulan Militan Gibran 08 Nusantara’ group, believes there are alleged violations of judicial ethics and conduct by the reported judges.

“I assess that the actions of the reported judges, specifically Vice Chairman of the MK, Professor Saldi Isra, which I have reported today, have been received by the MKMK secretariat at 14:50 WIB. I am reporting violations of judicial ethics and conduct by Vice Chairman Professor Saldi Isra, involving actions contrary to the principles of judicial power, namely that all parties must be heard in court, or the principle of ‘audi et alterandum partem’,” Rullyandi stated at the Constitutional Court in Jakarta on Friday (2/10).

He objected to Saldi’s decision to ask him to leave the courtroom without hearing his testimony as an expert for the related party, viewing the move as a form of discrimination. “I am an expert who was officially proposed in the hearing but was not permitted to provide oral testimony, only written testimony. This is a discriminatory act against me as a related party with a direct interest in the case being examined, namely this illegal hearing. This deeply wounds the Constitution and the 1945 Constitution as the supreme law,” he expressed.

Rullyandi also reported Arsul Sani for allegedly interfering with academic freedom. He stated that the judge questioned his clarification regarding his public statement that the second phase of the Presidential Election hearing was illegal, which Rullyandi views as an infringement on his freedom of thought.

Furthermore, Rullyandi reported Constitutional Court Chairman Suhartoyo, arguing that Suhartoyo’s current position as Chairman is invalid. He claimed that following a definitive ruling by the Administrative Court (PTUN) on 16 December 2024, there should be no definitive Chairman of the MK, and that Suhartoyo’s appointment based on a plenary meeting minutes that had been annulled by the PTUN is unlawful.

Based on these reports, Rullyandi hopes the presidential election dispute hearing for Gibran will be postponed until there is clarity regarding the MKMK report. The expulsion incident began when Judge Arsul Sani questioned Rullyandi regarding his television appearance where he claimed the MK proceedings were illegal.

“I happened to watch your talk show… where you stated that this proceeding is illegal and the Chairman of the MK is illegal. I request an explanation: if this hearing is illegal, why are you acting as an expert in this case? It concerns your consistency and credibility as an expert,” Arsul said.

Vice Chairman Saldi Isra added that Rullyandi must retract his statement that the proceedings were illegal, otherwise, he could not utilise his expertise in a hearing he claims is illegal. Rullyandi responded by retracting the statement, but only within the context of the current courtroom, stating he did so under pressure for the sake of the nation.

Following the exchange, Saldi ordered Rullyandi to leave the courtroom to maintain order, although the Court continued to accept the expert’s written testimony.

More from 2 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/gibrans-expert-files-complaint-against-constitutional-court-judges-to-ethics-council-1790945741)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261002172128-12-1411041/tak-terima-diusir-ahli-pihak-gibran-laporkan-saldi-isra-arsul-ke-mkmk), translated from Indonesian
Print