Gibran's Diploma Verdict Hearing Begins, Constitutional Court Emphasises Substantive Justice Over Formal Procedure
The Constitutional Court (MK) began the verdict reading for the 2024 Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Result Dispute (PHPU) case, numbered 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026, on Tuesday (6/10/2026) evening. The petition disputes the fulfilment of the educational requirements for Gibran Rakabuming Raka as a vice-presidential candidate.
At the start of the hearing, Constitutional Judge Saldi Isra stated that one of the Court’s authorities is to resolve election result disputes at the first and final instance, with a decision that is binding. This authority cannot be separated from the Court’s constitutional obligation as a constitutional judiciary that must ensure the election process remains within the corridors of the principles of direct, general, free, secret, honest, and fair elections.
“At this point, the position of the Constitutional Court cannot be detached from its role as the protector of the constitution or as the guardian of the constitution, as well as the guardian of democracy. According to the Court, this constitutional mandate means not merely positioning itself as a Court that only adjudicates the figures of election results, being bound by rigid procedures, but as the final bastion in safeguarding substantive justice,” said Salstra during the ongoing hearing.
Saldi touched upon the importance of substantive democracy in this case. He assessed that formal procedures must be secondary to the urgency of substantive democracy.
“Democracy must not be reduced to a merely mechanistic electoral effort, but must be understood within the framework of substantive democracy, such that formal procedural compliance must yield to the upholding of substantive justice,” Saldi stated.
It was noted that all constitutional judges were present at the verdict hearing this evening.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/gibrans-diploma-verdict-hearing-begins-constitutional-court-emphasises-substantive-justice-over-formal-1791298493)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tmhofl377/sidang-putusan-ijazah-gibran-dimulai-mk-singgung-keadilan-substantif-di-atas-prosedur-formal), translated from Indonesian