Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Gibran's Diploma Controversy Passed to Parliament

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Gibran's Diploma Controversy Passed to Parliament
Image: CNN Indonesia

The Constitutional Court (MK) has referred the follow-up regarding the ruling on the educational requirements for Vice President Gibrability Rakabuming Raka—specifically the lack of an equivalent high school diploma—to other authorised institutions. In its ruling, the MK stated it would not accept the petition in case number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026 concerning the Disputed Results of the 2024 Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election.

The MK stated it could not disqualify Gibran Rakabuming Raka as Vice President of Indonesia, even though it found no evidence of a high school diploma or its equivalent. Regarding the diploma requirements, the MK noted that the authority to assess the validity and fulfilment of candidate requirements substantially falls within the domain of institutions possessing such competence. Under the 1945 Constitution, this authority lies with the House of Representatives (DPR).

Criminal law expert from Trisakti University, Abdul Fickar Hajar, highlighted three major points in the MK’s decision. Abdul noted that the MK acted with restraint to avoid violating the constitution by not adjudicating the core merits of the case, while firmly refusing to expand its own authority. “The MK understands that this is the domain of disputes over presidential and vice-presidential election results, but besides being late in terms of timing, the petitioners also lacked legal standing,” Abdul Fickar stated on Wednesday.

However, Abdul suggested the MK was being tactical, redirecting the core issue towards impeachment, which falls under the jurisdiction of the DPR rather than the MK. “The brilliance of the MK lies in its strategy to shift the core issue to impeachment, which automatically moves it out of the MK’s competence and into the DPR’s. The MK essentially acts as a rubber stamp at the request of the DPR to bring this through the impeachment mechanism to the MPR,” Abdul wrote.

Constitutional law expert Bivitri Susanti also believes the MK has passed the ‘hot potato’ of Gibran’s diploma controversy to the DPR. “The MK has thrown the hot potato to: (1) political parties in the DPR to initiate impeachment; (2) law enforcement to investigate the manipulation discovered by the MK; and (3) the DPR to hold the KPU accountable so they are no longer elected, and should even be dismissed,” Bivitri wrote via her official Instagram account.

Bivitri views the MK’s ruling as being within its legal authority, given its role as a judicial institution that must adhere to its prescribed powers. Meanwhile, the authority to follow up lies with the DPR. “For impeachment, Article 7B of the Constitution states the DPR must act. The MK has helped uncover that there is an issue in Gibran’s candidacy. Therefore, the DPR is very much capable of following up on that ruling to initiate the impeachment process,” Bivitri told CNNIndonesia.com.

She added that the DPR now has grounds to initiate impeachment based on ‘unscrupulous conduct.’ Under Article 7A of the 1945 Constitution, a President or Vice President can be removed if they are proven to have committed serious offences, including ‘unscrupulous conduct.’ Under Article 7B, the DPR can propose such removal to the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR) after requesting the MK to examine the DPR’s findings.

The DPR has yet to issue a statement regarding the MK’s ruling. The Head of the Government Communications Agency (Bakom), Syahganda Nainggolan, stated that the government is waiting for the stance of non-executive institutions. “The ruling of the MK must be responded to by other state institutions outside the executive. The government is waiting,” Syahganda said via text message.

Syahganda noted that President Prabowo has fully entrusted the matter regarding Gibran’s case in the MK to the judicial branch. He emphasised that the government, specifically President Prabowo, is not attempting to intervene in the Constitutional Court. “This is to demonstrate that the government is not attempting any legal intervention in the Judiciary,” he said.

The MK read its decision regarding the lawsuit filed by Denny Indrayana and others concerning Gibran’s high school diploma on Tuesday night. One fact revealed in the ruling was that the MK found no documents proving Gibran possesses a diploma as evidence of completing overseas education equivalent to high school.

“After the Court studied all evidence presented by the parties and the facts revealed in the trial, the Court found no documents showing Gibran Rakabuming Raka possesses a diploma/certificate/diploma as proof of completing overseas education equivalent to High School as intended in the Election Law,” stated Constitutional Judge Arsul Sani. It was reported that when registering as a vice-presidential candidate, Gibran only submitted a Certificate of Attendance and transcripts, which are insufficient documentation.

More from 7 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/gibrans-diploma-controversy-passed-to-parliament-1791352606)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261007095038-32-1412535/bola-panas-polemik-ijazah-gibran-bergulir-ke-dpr), translated from Indonesian
Print