Gibran’s Diploma Controversy Continues to Unfold
The validity of the education-equivalency certificate used by Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka to meet the requirements for standing as a vice-presidential candidate in the 2024 presidential election remains in dispute.
The issue has continued to unfold after the Supreme Court, at cassation level, ruled that Gibran’s certificate was invalid.
H M Subhan, the plaintiff in the case, urged Gibran to resign from office. He gave Gibran an ultimatum to leave the Presidential Palace within the next two months.
Subhan said the Supreme Court’s cassation ruling carried the legal consequence that Gibran was an illegitimate vice-president.
“I have counted the days: if he has not left the Palace within the next 60 days, I will come and ask him to return to Solo,” Subhan said at a press conference at the Integrity law firm’s office in Jakarta on Monday (2 November).
Calls for Parliament to initiate impeachment
In the dispute over the certificate, Gibran faces former deputy law and human rights minister Denny Indrayana, who previously brought the matter before the Constitutional Court. Denny also spoke to the press alongside Subhan about the case.
Denny said it would be an affront to the rule of law if Parliament did not pursue impeachment proceedings against Gibran following the ruling.
He urged the House of Representatives (DPR) to initiate the process in response to the decision. Denny said the ruling came not only from the Supreme Court but also followed similar reasoning by the Constitutional Court.
“If no impeachment effort is made, we are watching, in plain sight, a betrayal of the principle of the rule of law,” Denny said.
Following the decisions by the two courts, Denny urged the DPR to act by exercising its right to express an opinion. He said Parliament should state that Gibran no longer met the education requirements stipulated in the Election Law.
“If the DPR, the Parliament, takes no action, that also means we are allowing defiance of the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court rulings,” he said.
As well as advocating Gibran’s impeachment, Denny said he would write to the Ombudsman over alleged maladministration. The letter concerns alleged violations by the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education.
“We sent a letter to the ministry almost two weeks ago and copied in the Ombudsman. Now it is time to write to the Ombudsman to make clear that there has been an administrative violation—maladministration by the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education,” he said.
Denny also explained that, once a president and vice-president have taken office, impeachment does not have to be pursued against them as a pair.
“The pair arrangement applies in the context of candidate pairs under the election regime. A presidential candidate and a vice-presidential candidate are called a candidate pair. They are a pair under the election regime,” he said.
Gibran supporters respond
Separately, Gibranisti volunteer group chairman Taufik Bilfaqih said the Supreme Court ruling did not affect Gibran’s legitimacy as vice-president.
He said the ruling was not retroactive and would apply going forward. Taufik also said Gibran had not breached the Constitution when he stood as a vice-presidential candidate in the 2024 election, and noted that the General Elections Commission (KPU) had approved his candidacy documents at the time.
“The certificate has been revoked, and that actually applies to the future; it does not apply to the past, when he stood as a vice-presidential candidate,” he said.
Taufik said Gibran was not surprised by the Supreme Court’s cassation ruling and had responded calmly.
“Mr Vice-President is not the sort of person who gets easily startled. He is cool, he is not surprised, and he does not feel he has done anything wrong,” he said.
Taufik said the group also respected the political process in the DPR, describing it as part of democratic dynamics. He suggested the current narrative was an attempt to undermine Gibran’s legitimacy because he is the son of Indonesia’s seventh president, Joko Widodo.
“They are connecting the dots as if, because he is the President’s son, he was given special treatment and received a certificate by magic. But that is not the case, is it? He followed the proper process,” he said.
The controversy continued after the Supreme Court, in its cassation ruling, granted the plaintiff’s claim in full. The decision, No. 742 K/TUN/2026, was handed down on Friday, 30 October 2026.
“Cassation granted, lower court judgment overturned, case decided on its merits: plaintiff’s claim granted in full,” the Supreme Court’s official website said on Monday (2 November).
Subhan, as plaintiff, asked the panel of judges for four forms of relief. He sued the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education, represented in the case by its secretary-general.
First, he asked the court to grant the claim in full. Second, he sought a declaration that Certificate No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, issued in Jakarta on 6 August 2019 by the Directorate General of Primary and Secondary Education, was invalid and void by law.
Third, he asked the court to order that the certificate be retrieved from whoever held it and destroyed. Finally, he asked the defendant to pay the court costs.
At cassation level, Yulius presided over the panel, joined by three member judges: Maftuh Effendi, the first member judge, and Hari Sugiharto, the second member judge. Michael Renaldy Zein served as substitute registrar.
The case had initially been dismissed at first instance, under case number 62/G/2026/PTUN.JKT, in a ruling issued on 21 May 2026. The panel ruled that the plaintiff’s claim was inadmissible.
The case then went to appeal under decision No. 130/B/2026/PT.TUN.JKT, in which the panel upheld the first-instance ruling.
Separate from the Supreme Court case, Gibran’s qualifications were also challenged before the Constitutional Court.
In its ruling, the Constitutional Court said it had found no convincing evidence that Gibran held a foreign diploma, certificate or degree that could serve as a basis for equivalency with the requirement of having completed at least senior secondary school or an equivalent institution, as set out in Articles 169(r) and 227(l) of the Election Law.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/gibrans-diploma-controversy-continues-to-unfold-1793670693)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261103063220-20-1422544/bola-polemik-ijazah-gibran-terus-menggelinding), translated from Indonesian