Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Gibran's Claims and Constitutional Court Ruling Diverge, Former Judge Highlights the Consequences: This Is Dangerous

| Source: VIVA.co.id Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Gibran's Claims and Constitutional Court Ruling Diverge, Former Judge Highlights the Consequences: This Is Dangerous
Image: VIVA.co.id

Former Constitutional Court judge Patrialis Akbar has drawn attention to Constitutional Court Ruling No. 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026, which stated that no evidence was found of a senior high school diploma or equivalent held by Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka.

Patrialis said the finding runs counter to Gibran’s public assurances that he does hold a diploma equivalent to senior high school.

First, Patrialis questioned why the Court never summoned Gibran during the proceedings before the verdict was handed down.

“The question is, didn’t it occur to the Constitutional Court judges that, suddenly, Mas Gibran might show his diploma, when he was never confirmed or brought to the hearing? I was also surprised. Mas Gibran said, ‘If I hadn’t graduated from senior high school, I couldn’t have studied in Singapore.’ Meanwhile, the legal counsel had already stressed and urged that Mas Gibran be summoned, but this was not done. Yet the ruling concerns a person who was never called,” Patrialis said on tvOne on Thursday (8/10/2026).

Patrialis argued that the matter would become considerably more complicated if Gibran later presented his original diploma.

He also raised the question of how the judges handling the case would be held accountable.

“If, let’s say, there are further developments or other efforts and Mas Gibran then shows his original diploma, I only ask what the moral accountability of the nine Constitutional Court judges, whose status is that of statesmen, would be. Would that accountability be heavy?” he said.

Patrialis believes the Court should have summoned the party who was the subject of the case directly, particularly when it concerns a person’s documents and personal status.

In his view, Gibran’s attendance at the hearing would have been important to verify directly the accuracy of the educational documents at the centre of the dispute.

As a former Constitutional Court judge, Patrialis stressed that the Court should have asked Gibran to produce the educational documents before drawing conclusions in its ruling.

He further highlighted the consequences should problems emerge after the ruling was read, questioning how the judges would account for them.

“In my view, because this concerns a person, and the person is there, he should be summoned formally. If he doesn’t want to come formally, then announce it. But it’s unlikely he wouldn’t come, because he is the Vice President, and he also has an ethical obligation to attend, in my opinion,” Patrialis said.

Tags: berita

More from 8 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/gibrans-claims-and-constitutional-court-ruling-diverge-former-judge-highlights-the-consequences-this-is-1791442612)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1934175-pengakuan-gibran-dan-putusan-mk-bertolak-belakang-mantan-hakim-konstitusi-singgung-konsekuensinya-ini-bahaya), translated from Indonesian
Print