Gibran Says He Will ‘Fight’ Through the State Administrative Court; Denny Indrayana Calls It Constitutional Disobedience
JAKARTA — Constitutional law expert Denny Indrayana said Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s plan to fight through the State Administrative Court (PTUN) against rulings by the Constitutional Court (MK) and Supreme Court (MA) amounted to defiance of the Constitution. The former Deputy Minister of Law and Human Rights stressed that, following the two court rulings, Gibran should formally announce his resignation in public.
“If he does not respect the rulings of the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court, that is constitutional disobedience. This is a very poor example from the perspective of the ethics of state governance,” Denny said, quoted from his personal YouTube channel in Jakarta on Wednesday (11 November 2026).
Denny emphasised that the decisions of both judicial institutions were final and binding and had acquired permanent legal force, leaving no further legal recourse. He said he had received a copy of the Supreme Court ruling granting the cancellation of Gibran’s certificate of equivalency for his senior secondary education.
The ruling ordered the relevant ministry to revoke the certificate, in order to protect democracy from a structured, systematic and planned violation (TSM). With the certificate annulled, Denny said, the subject of the lawsuit at the State Administrative Court had automatically ceased to exist.
“The point is that once the ruling clearly states its order and legal reasoning, the certificate can no longer serve as a basis. The case at the State Administrative Court has effectively lost its object,” Denny said.
On the possibility of a judicial review (PK), Denny said Gibran had no legal standing because he was not a party to the case. He also said that, under the Constitutional Court’s ruling on the judicial review of Law No. 24 of 2024, state administrative bodies or institutions, such as ministries, were prohibited from seeking a judicial review of a State Administrative Court decision.
“The two steps they say they will take to fight are not only inconsistent with legal theory and concepts, but once again show a capacity that is simply not at the level required to be vice-president,” he said.
Denny said Article 7(2) of Law No. 30 of 2014 on Government Administration legally obliges officials to implement decisions that have permanent legal force.
“I regret what Mr Gibran said earlier. I hope he listens to this and understands that the longer he takes to make a wise decision, the worse it will be for him. Moreover, proceedings have already begun in the House of Representatives,” he said.
Denny praised members of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI) for initiating the right to express an opinion (HMP), and urged them to expedite the impeachment process against Gibran and complete it within three weeks.
He said the DPR was right to use the HMP procedure without first pursuing the right of interpellation, given that the legal basis—the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court rulings—was clear. He said the minimum requirement of 25 lawmakers to propose an HMP had already been exceeded.
“After it is proposed and approved and a special committee is established, I calculate that it should take no more than a week. The matter then goes to the Constitutional Court. Although the Court has 90 days, a preliminary hearing, the vice-president’s response, the evidentiary stage and closing submissions should be enough to complete it in a week. By the third week, the process would be back in the DPR,” he said.
He said that if the DPR approved impeachment with a quorum of three-quarters of its members present and the support of two-thirds of those members, the vice-presidency would be declared vacant. This would trigger the mechanism under Article 8(2) of the 1945 Constitution, under which President Prabowo Subianto would propose two vice-presidential candidates for the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR) to elect.
“I urge that we move quickly to implement Article 8(2), not only to provide political certainty, but also economic certainty. We need to resolve this issue promptly,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/gibran-says-he-will-fight-through-the-state-administrative-court-denny-indrayana-calls-it-constitutional-1794387211)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tobw55409/gibran-nyatakan-fight-lewat-ptun-denny-indrayana-itu-pembangkangan-konstitusi), translated from Indonesian