Gibran Faces a Legal Dead End in Proving His Diploma’s Validity
Bivitri Susanti, founder of the Indonesian Centre for Legal Studies and a constitutional law expert, said Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka could no longer continue to prove the validity of his secondary-school-equivalency certificate through legal channels, including the State Administrative Court (PTUN).
“So it actually cannot be pursued further, because there has already been a ruling declaring it null and void. That ruling is final. In law, ‘null and void’ means the certificate is considered never to have existed, and its legal consequences cannot exist either,” Bivitri said in a text message on Wednesday (11 November).
Bivitri noted that Constitutional Court ruling No. 24/PUU-XXII/2024 states that a defendant in a state administrative dispute cannot file for judicial review (PK).
Therefore, in Gibran’s case, the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education, as the defendant, cannot seek judicial review of the Supreme Court’s cassation-level ruling.
The Constitutional Court ruling No. 24/PUU-XXII/2024 reasoned that the State Administrative Court is a forum for citizens to challenge the conduct of state administrative officials.
“That is the context in terms of judicial power: it is there to protect the interests of citizens, especially when they are dealing with the government,” she said.
Regarding the Supreme Court’s ruling on Gibran’s certificate of secondary-school equivalency, Bivitri stressed that it was issued at cassation level and is now final and legally binding.
As a result, she said Gibran had no further legal avenue available, including the State Administrative Court route he intended to pursue.
“To me, it looks like Gibran is trying to find a way out of this situation,” she said.
Bivitri said the consequence of the Supreme Court ruling was that Gibran’s certificate was null and void.
“Even if the State Administrative Court continues with the case—as Gibran’s lawyers have asked it to do—if the judges act properly, they are now required to proceed. But in the end, the ruling will surely say the case is inadmissible, because there is already that Supreme Court decision, in which Mr Subhan was the applicant and plaintiff,” she said.
Gibran’s effort to prove the validity of his certificate came to light after reports that he had asked to step down from office.
State Secretary Prasetyo Hadi said Gibran had met President Prabowo on Tuesday (10 November). He said that during the meeting Gibran asked for time to prove the validity of his certificate through the State Administrative Court.
“Vice-President Gibran also asked to be given the opportunity to prove the validity of the documents he holds through the State Administrative Court process,” Prasetyo said at the Presidential Palace in Jakarta.
Gibran said that during their meeting, Prabowo had advised him to continue fighting the case through the State Administrative Court.
“He gave me a great deal of advice and input on the current developments. One of his suggestions was that I should continue to fight in the State Administrative Court, presenting all my documents from primary school through to my bachelor’s degree, and coordinate with the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education to file for judicial review at the Supreme Court,” Gibran said at the Vice-Presidential Palace in Jakarta.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/gibran-faces-a-legal-dead-end-in-proving-his-diplomas-validity-1794390911)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261111155346-32-1425948/jalan-buntu-gibran-buktikan-ijazah-di-meja-hijau), translated from Indonesian