Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Getting Non-Automatic Grade Promotion Right and Fair

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Getting Non-Automatic Grade Promotion Right and Fair
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Repeating a year without improving the approach to learning risks causing pupils to face the same difficulties for a second time.

Jakarta (ANTARA) – The policy of non-automatic grade promotion in primary and secondary education needs to be discussed as more than a simple choice between promoting or not promoting pupils.

The more fundamental question is how to ensure that such decisions are genuinely appropriate, fair and supportive of each pupil’s learning development.

The policy may be intended to maintain competency standards, but without a reliable decision-making system, this good intention could instead harm pupils and create new problems.

Grade promotion is not the goal of education. The main goal is to ensure that every pupil has the opportunity to develop the required competencies.

Therefore, a decision not to promote a pupil to the next year can only be justified when there is sufficient evidence that the pupil has not achieved essential competencies, after being given the necessary learning opportunities and support.

The question is not simply whether a pupil deserves to move up a year, but whether the school has a sufficiently strong basis for making that decision.

Two risks

Educational measurement and evaluation involve two types of decision-making errors that must be anticipated. The first is a false negative decision: a pupil who has in fact met the required competencies is wrongly judged not ready for promotion. The second is a false positive decision: a pupil who has not met those competencies is nevertheless promoted.

The two errors have different consequences. The first can cause pupils to lose learning time, undermine their motivation and make them feel unfairly treated. The second can allow competency gaps to carry over into the next year, making it increasingly difficult for pupils to keep up with lessons.

Therefore, a non-automatic promotion policy must not focus solely on preventing the promotion of pupils who have not mastered the required competencies. It must also prevent the mistake of holding back pupils who have met the requirements.

A good decision is not one that holds back the greatest number of pupils, but one that is most accurate and can be properly justified.

Four technical requirements

More from 14 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/getting-non-automatic-grade-promotion-right-and-fair-1791946319)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5784961/kenaikan-kelas-non-otomatis-yang-tepat-dan-adil), translated from Indonesian
Print