General Gatot Urges Meritocracy in TNI Leadership, Warns Against Political Proximity
Meritocracy must be the primary foundation in determining leadership within the Indonesian National Armed Forces (TNI). TNI commander for the 2015-2017 period, General (ret.) Gatot Nurmantyo, reminded that if promotions and postings are no longer based on achievement, capability, morals, ethics, education and experience, the professionalism and neutrality of the TNI will be threatened.
“When meritocracy is truly upheld, then only people of achievement will lead the TNI,” Gatot said in the webinar “You Ask, General Gatot Answers”, held by Indonesia Strategic and Defence Studies (ISDS) in Jakarta on Wednesday (19/8/2026).
According to the former Army chief of staff, the merit system within the TNI was built through a long process considering various aspects, from psychology, morals, ethics and education to experience. From that process, Gatot said, only the best soldiers are then projected to occupy leadership levels.
Therefore, Gatot warned of the danger when that system is replaced by political proximity, family relations or other non-professional factors. Such conditions can cause frustration among soldiers who have worked hard and risked their lives in carrying out their duties. “What was the point of me going to Papua until I bled, what was the point of my struggle, but it turns out the one promoted is a salon soldier,” he said.
Gatot even described soldiers who pursue positions through political proximity as “political prostitutes”. He believes soldiers must not have such an orientation. “I apologise if I am rather harsh, but people like that are political prostitutes. Soldiers must not be like that. They should only work, work, work for the best of this nation. Let rank itself be the reward,” he said.
Gatot stated that the breakdown of meritocracy can also threaten TNI neutrality. If soldiers see positions being given not because of capability and achievement, but because of closeness to certain political forces or elites, trust in the system will collapse.
Gatot stressed that the TNI is one of the main pillars in safeguarding state sovereignty. Therefore, TNI leadership must be filled by soldiers who possess capability, experience, courage and professionalism.
“The main pillar for safeguarding sovereignty is the TNI. When the TNI is led by people who have never been to war or are afraid of war, and can only wage a war of words, then it is finished,” Gatot said.
In addition, Gatot also emphasised that the military’s primary orientation must remain on the capability to face war. The organisational and rank structure, he continued, must be adjusted to defence needs so that the TNI can become an effective, small, agile organisation capable of responding to threats.
“The TNI’s domain of thought is war. Organisation and rank only adjust to war. That is more effective, smaller, more agile. That is the military,” Gatot explained.
Gatot said the criticism was delivered out of concern for the future of the TNI. He explained that meritocracy is not merely an internal organisational matter, but an important foundation to ensure the TNI remains professional, solid, neutral and capable of carrying out its duties as guardian of state sovereignty together with the people.
Gatot also highlighted the importance of defence modernisation as well as strengthening the domestic defence industry. He said strengthening the TNI is not enough through the addition of primary weapon systems (alutsista), but must be directed at improving capability, interoperability and mastery of strategic technology, including cyber technology.
Gatot also reminded that the TNI must remain within a professional corridor and not be drawn into practical politics or given tasks outside its authority. According to him, deviation from those priorities could open space for larger problems.
In addition to strengthening the TNI, Gatot believes the government must consistently build the national defence industry. Indonesia, according to him, must have the ability to produce and maintain defence systems independently. “In time, Indonesia must be able to produce and maintain defence systems independently,” said the former Pangkostrad.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/general-gatot-urges-meritocracy-in-tni-leadership-warns-against-political-proximity-1787201620)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tk1w4w484/jenderal-gatot-ingatkan-meritrokasi-ditegakkan-tni-dipimpin-orang-berprestasi), translated from Indonesian