Furore Erupts After Indonesian President’s Phone Call Is Tapped and Secret Conversation Leaked
Indonesia was rocked in February 1999 by a wiretapping scandal involving a conversation between the country’s third president, B.J. Habibie, and Attorney General Andi Muhammad Ghalib. A recording of their phone call was intercepted and made public, prompting controversy because it discussed the questioning of Indonesia’s second president, Soeharto, in an alleged corruption case.
The incident came to light on 17 February 1999, after Panji Masyarakat magazine published the entire recording. The conversation, believed to have taken place between Habibie and Ghalib, concerned the investigation into alleged corruption by Soeharto.
One point of contention was the length of the questioning. South China Morning Post reported on 19 February 1999 that Habibie asked how long Soeharto had been questioned. Ghalib then said how long the examination needed to last so it would not look like a sham.
“How many hours for him?” Habibie asked.
“More than three hours,” Ghalib replied.
“Right, that’s enough,” Habibie said.
“Yes, but if it’s only two hours, people will say, ‘What sort of sham is this now?’” Ghalib said.
The conversation was believed to have taken place on 10 December 1998, a day after Soeharto was questioned. Before it was published, the recording had reportedly circulated from person to person among members of the public and activists.
“A few days later, there were already rumours that a tape recording of the intercepted Habibie-Ghalib conversation, concerning Soeharto’s questioning, was circulating,” Tempo reported on 22 February 1999.
The recording eventually reached journalists. Panji Masyarakat decided to publish the full conversation after seeking confirmation from the parties concerned.
The publication immediately caused a political uproar. The conversation was seen as showing that the government was not serious about investigating the allegations against Soeharto. Some also suggested that those in power were interfering in the legal process.
Criticism came from various quarters, including Benny Harman, deputy chair of the Indonesian Advocates Association (SPI). He said the incident exposed a serious problem in law enforcement.
“The incident showed the public just how the law was being trampled by those in power,” Benny Harman told Kompas on 23 February 1999.
Amid the controversy, Habibie ordered the military to investigate the suspected wiretap. He neither confirmed nor denied that the recording of the conversation attributed to him was genuine. Speaking at Merdeka Palace, Habibie became angry and described the interception and leak of the conversation as a crime.
“That is intellectual criminal acts,” Habibie said, according to the Bali Post on 24 February 1999.
Habibie considered the interception of a confidential conversation dangerous and said it should not be carried out arbitrarily. He stated that it could only be conducted by ABRI intelligence (now the Indonesian National Armed Forces, or TNI) with the commander’s authorisation, when there were indications of an attempted coup.
The then ABRI commander, Wiranto, also denied that ABRI intelligence was involved. He said that the ability to intercept communications was not limited to official bodies and could also be acquired freely.
“I can assure you that the ability to intercept communications is not held only by official bodies or institutions, whether the government or ABRI. Why? I can assure you that this equipment is sold freely in Singapore and Hong Kong,” Wiranto said, according to the Bali Post on 24 February 1999.
Wiranto also stressed that ABRI intelligence had never ordered the interception of conversations involving state officials. He said ABRI was instead trying to establish whether the voices on the recording really belonged to Habibie and Ghalib.
Meanwhile, the police formed a special team to investigate the case. Among those summoned was Uni Zulfkili Lubis, deputy editor-in-chief of Panji Masyarakat.
According to the Bali Post on 20 February 1999, Lubis was asked to appear at national police headquarters for questioning. She was questioned for six hours alongside two colleagues, with lawyer T. Mulya Lubis present. The three were witnesses in a case concerning the dissemination of news alleged to have caused public disorder.
Although the wiretapping case briefly sparked a national controversy, it eventually faded without resolution. Investigators failed to identify who had intercepted and leaked the conversation between Habibie and Ghalib.