Full Supreme Court Ruling Cancels Gibran’s High School Equivalency Certificate
The Supreme Court (MA) has released the full text of its ruling in case Number 742 K/TUN/2026, which annulled the certificate equating Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s education with senior secondary schooling. The ruling was handed down on 30 October 2026.
Subhan’s lawsuit was initially declared inadmissible by the Jakarta Administrative Court. He appealed, but the Jakarta High Administrative Court upheld the lower court’s ruling. Subhan then lodged a cassation appeal, which the Supreme Court granted.
Eleven days after the ruling was handed down, the full text of case Number 742 K/TUN/2026 was released on Tuesday, 10 November 2026.
The following is the full Supreme Court ruling in the case:
RULING
Number 742 K/TUN/2026
IN THE NAME OF JUSTICE UNDER THE ONE ALMIGHTY GOD
THE SUPREME COURT
Having examined an administrative court case at cassation level, has ruled as follows in the case between:
H.M. SUBHAN, S.H., M.H., an Indonesian citizen and private-sector employee;
Cassation Applicant;
-versus-
THE DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF PRIMARY AND SECONDARY EDUCATION AT THE MINISTRY OF EDUCATION AND CULTURE OF THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA, based at the Ministry of Education and Culture complex, Jalan Jenderal Sudirman, Senayan, Central Jakarta 10270, with electronic domicile at bantuan.hukum@kemdikbud.go.id;
In this case represented by Muhammad Ravii, S.H., M.M., a civil servant at the Ministry of Education and Culture of the Republic of Indonesia, and colleagues, under Special Power of Attorney Number 0002/C/HK/10/2026 dated 14 April 2026;
Cassation Respondent;
The Supreme Court;
Having read the relevant documents, which form an integral part of this ruling;
Considering that, on the basis of the relevant documents, the plaintiff asked the Court to rule as follows:
Grant the plaintiff’s claim in its entirety;
Declare null and void or unlawful the Certificate of the Director-General of Primary and Secondary Education at the Ministry of Education and Culture of the Republic of Indonesia Number 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, dated 6 August 2019;
Order the defendant to revoke the Certificate of the Director-General of Primary and Secondary Education at the Ministry of Education and Culture of the Republic of Indonesia Number 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, dated 6 August 2019;
Order the defendant to pay the legal costs;
Considering that, in response to the claim, the defendant raised preliminary objections, principally concerning:
The expiry of the time limit for filing the claim;
The plaintiff’s legal standing;
The failure to join all necessary parties (plurium litis consortium);
Considering that the Jakarta Administrative Court declared the claim inadmissible in Ruling Number 62/G/2026/PTUN.JKT, dated 21 May 2026, and that the Jakarta High Administrative Court upheld that ruling on appeal in Ruling Number 130/B/2026/PT.TUN.JKT, dated 12 August 2026;
Considering that, after the latter ruling was notified to the Cassation Applicant on 12 August 2026, the applicant lodged a cassation appeal on 24 August 2026. The appeal was accompanied by a cassation brief setting out the grounds, uploaded on 24 August 2026 and verified by the registry of the Jakarta Administrative Court on 28 August 2026;
Considering that the cassation application and its grounds were duly notified to the opposing party, and were submitted within the prescribed time limit and in the manner provided by law; accordingly, the application is formally admissible;
Considering that, in the Cassation Brief, which forms an integral part of this ruling, the Cassation Applicant requested that the Court:
Accept the cassation application;
Declare null and void, unlawful and without binding legal force the Jakarta Administrative Court Ruling Number 62/G/2026/PTUN.JKT, dated 21 May 2026;
Declare null and void, unlawful and without binding legal force the Jakarta High Administrative Court Ruling Number 130/B/2026/PT.TUN.JKT, dated 12 August 2026;
Rule the case itself at cassation level:
Grant the plaintiff’s claim in its entirety;
Declare null and void or unlawful the Certificate of the Director-General of Primary and Secondary Education at the Ministry of Education and Culture of the Republic of Indonesia Number 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, dated 6 August 2019;
Order the defendant to revoke the Certificate of the Director-General of Primary and Secondary Education at the Ministry of Education and Culture of the Republic of Indonesia Number 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, dated 6 August 2019;
Order the defendant to pay the legal costs;
Considering that the Cassation Respondent submitted a response to the cassation brief, uploaded on 10 September 2026 and verified on 14 September 2026, essentially asking the Court to reject the cassation application;
Considering the grounds for cassation, the Supreme Court holds as follows:
Considering that, irrespective of the grounds advanced by the Cassation Applicant, the lower courts made an error of law for the following reasons:
The Administrative Court cannot hear and decide disputes arising from the electoral process—special administrative disputes—because of limits on the parties, subject matter and time allowed for resolution. However, once that period has elapsed, an administrative violation that is structured, systematic and planned, and that threatens democracy and the people’s sovereignty to choose the best-qualified candidate, may be addressed through the Administrative Court’s corrective and remedial authority to halt its effects;
In the Supreme Court’s view, the administrative violation at issue concerns not merely the interests of electoral candidates but those of the entire Indonesian nation. Anyone with the right to vote and stand for election should therefore be entitled to bring a claim. The Cassation Applicant, formerly the plaintiff, is an Indonesian citizen entitled to vote and stand for election as President and/or Vice-President under the applicable law. That interest is one the law must protect in upholding the rules governing elections, including the requirements for a vice-presidential candidate set out in Article 169(r) of Law Number 7 of 2017 on General Elections, as amended by Law Number 7 of 2023 concerning the enactment of Government Regulation in Lieu of Law Number 1 of 2022 amending Law Number 7 of 2017 on General Elections;
A new legal fact has emerged in the form of Constitutional Court Ruling Number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026, dated 5 October 2026. The Supreme Court considers this a matter of common knowledge (notoire feiten). The Constitutional Court’s legal reasoning examined the subject of the present dispute, changing the legal circumstances and affecting the status of the disputed decision, which is now inconsistent with the existing legal order;
In light of this new legal situation, the Supreme Court considers it legally justified to set aside the Cassation Respondent’s preliminary objections concerning the time limit for filing the claim and the failure to join all necessary parties (plurium litis consortium). As court rulings form part of the legal system, substantive justice should take precedence over procedural justice. The Supreme Court will therefore examine the substance of the disputed decision to give concrete effect to Constitutional Court Ruling Number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026, dated 5 October 2026, and to give effect to the principle ius curia novit. The defendant’s preliminary objections are therefore unfounded in law;
As a matter of fact, the disputed decision was issued by the Cassation Respondent, formerly the defendant, on the basis of a certificate of attendance, academic records, an explanation of grades and other documents that do not prove that Gibran Rakabuming Raka completed a particular level of education. They only record his attendance at classes. More specifically, no evidence was found that Gibran Rakabuming Raka held an overseas diploma or certificate that could be used as the basis for equivalence with senior high school, vocational high school or an equivalent qualification;
Equating an education programme using an international or foreign curriculum with one using the national curriculum without supporting evidence of a diploma, certificate or other qualification awarded upon completion is an imprudent act that affects the material facts underlying a decision. The Cassation Respondent’s issuance of the disputed decision therefore breached the principle of formal diligence;
Considering that, on the basis of the above reasoning, the Supreme Court finds sufficient grounds to grant the cassation application without needing to consider the other grounds of appeal;
Considering that the Jakarta High Administrative Court Ruling Number 130/B/2026/PT.TUN.JKT, dated 12 August 2026, which upheld the Jakarta Administrative Court Ruling Number 62/G/2026/PTUN.JKT, dated 21 May 2026, cannot stand and must be set aside. The Supreme Court will decide the case itself as set out in the ruling below;
Considering that the Supreme Court has read and examined the response to the cassation brief but found nothing capable of undermining the Cassation Applicant’s arguments;
Considering that, as the cassation application has been granted and the Cassation Respondent has lost the case, the respondent must pay the legal costs at all court levels;
Having regard to the provisions of Law Number 48 of 2009 on Judicial Power; Law Number 14 of 1985 on the Supreme Court, as amended by Law Number 5 of 2004 and the second amendment, Law Number 3 of 2009; Law Number 5 of 1986 on Administrative Courts, as amended by Law Number 9 of 2004 and the second amendment, Law Number 51 of 2009; and other relevant laws and regulations;
THE COURT RULES:
To grant the cassation application of H.M. SUBHAN, S.H., M.H., the Cassation Applicant;
To set aside the Jakarta High Administrative Court Ruling Number 130/B/2026/PT.TUN.JKT, dated 12 August 2026, which upheld the Jakarta Administrative Court Ruling Number 62/G/2026/PTUN.JKT, dated 21 May 2026;
DECIDING THE CASE ITSELF:
On the preliminary objections:
- To declare the defendant’s preliminary objections inadmissible;
On the merits:
To grant the plaintiff’s claim in its entirety;
To declare null and void the Certificate of the Director-General of Primary and Secondary Education at the Ministry of Education and Culture of the Republic of Indonesia Number 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, dated 6 August 2019;
To order the defendant to revoke the Certificate of the Director-General of Primary and Secondary Education at the Ministry of Education and Culture of the Republic of Indonesia Number 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, dated 6 August 2019;
To order the Cassation Respondent to pay the legal costs at all court levels, with the costs at cassation level set at Rp400,000 (four hundred thousand rupiah);
The ruling was handed down at a judges’ deliberation meeting on Friday, 30 October 2026, by Prof. Dr. H. Yulius, S.H., M.H., Deputy Chief Justice for Administrative Affairs at the Supreme Court, appointed by the Chief Justice as presiding judge, together with Dr. Maftuh Effendi, S.H., M.H., and Dr. H. Hari Sugiharto, S.H., M.H., Supreme Court Justices. It was pronounced in open court on the same day by the presiding judge, in the presence of the other justices and Michael Renaldy Zein, S.H., M.H., deputy registrar, with the parties absent.
Panel members:
Signed
Dr. Maftuh Effendi, S.H., M.H.
Signed
Dr. H. Hari Sugiharto, S.H., M.H.
Presiding judge,
Signed
Prof. Dr. H. Yulius, S.H., M.H.
Deputy registrar,
Signed
Michael Renaldy Zein, S.H., M.H.
Costs:
Stamp duty: Rp10,000
Drafting fee: Rp10,000
Cassation administration: Rp380,000
Total: Rp400,000
For the certified copy
Supreme Court of the Republic of Indonesia
For the Registrar,
Deputy Registrar for Administrative Affairs,
Electronically signed
H. Hendro Puspito, S.H., M.Hum.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/full-supreme-court-ruling-cancels-gibrans-high-school-equivalency-certificate-1794307896)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8746999/ini-putusan-lengkap-ma-batalkan-suket-ijazah-sma-gibran), translated from Indonesian