Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

From the State Budget to Intelligent Fiscal Orchestration

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Technology
From the State Budget to Intelligent Fiscal Orchestration
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Each year, discussion of the State Budget (APBN) tends to centre on the scale of revenue, higher expenditure, a widening deficit, debt burdens and limited fiscal space. It is as if the success of fiscal policy were determined by the government’s ability to keep these figures in balance.

Yet the more fundamental question is how far the APBN can mobilise the productive capacity of the national economy. A large budget does not automatically produce high-quality growth. Higher spending does not necessarily strengthen productivity. Even fiscal stability, on its own, does not guarantee structural transformation.

In Simatupang’s 2026 articles, The Orchestrator State for 8% Growth and Political Bubble vs Orchestrator, the argument is made that the state cannot simply act as regulator, tax collector or budget spender. It must serve as a conductor, aligning different economic forces with the development goals set out in the APBN Law.

Today, the development of Agentic Artificial Intelligence (Agentic AI) (Konverge AI, 2026) offers new possibilities for translating this idea into more concrete governance mechanisms.

Through Intelligent Fiscal Orchestration, the state could build a system that does more than read APBN figures: it could connect policies, anticipate risks, coordinate implementation and continuously assess development outcomes.

The APBN paradox: a large budget does not necessarily deliver impact

The 2027 APBN, which has been approved, sets state revenue at Rp3,435.1 trillion, state expenditure at Rp4,106.3 trillion and budget financing at Rp671.2 trillion, with a deficit of 2.4% of gross domestic product (GDP). These figures reflect the significant role of fiscal policy in supporting growth, social protection and the national development agenda (Finance Ministry, 29 September 2026).

But a substantial spending capacity may not be enough to meet future challenges. How much productivity, investment, employment and added value does each rupiah of the APBN generate?

Our problem is not a lack of resources, but a disconnect between policy instruments. This is where the fiscal paradox emerges: the state may succeed in spending its budget without successfully orchestrating its impact. APBN management must therefore shift from an emphasis on disbursement to productivity, from a sectoral approach to connected policymaking, and from administrative evaluation to measuring development outcomes.

From sectoral policies to economic harmony

The Orchestrator State concept starts from the premise that growth results from interaction among investment, productivity, technology, labour, financing, infrastructure and institutional quality. This thinking is close to the developmental state approach, which emphasises state institutional capacity (Evans, 1995), and mission-oriented innovation policy, which positions the state as directing investment and innovation towards specific development goals (Mazzucato, 2018).

The Orchestrator State does not mean a state that dominates the market. Rather, the state must create conditions in which the government, state-owned enterprises (SOEs), banks, private investors and local governments can each play a productive role within a framework of national objectives.

From this perspective, the APBN performs five strategic functions: directing resource allocation (strategic allocator), driving investment (economic catalyst), absorbing shocks (risk absorber), integrating development (development integrator) and measuring policy outcomes (performance governor).

These five functions cannot be performed effectively if each ministry and agency operates within its own policy domain. The Orchestrator State requires a capability that has long challenged the bureaucracy: understanding policy connections as a whole, detecting misalignment early and correcting implementation before resources lose their effectiveness.

Agentic AI: when the state gains orchestration intelligence

AI has until now been best known for generating text, drafting reports, answering questions and processing information. Agentic AI, however, offers a different approach (Konverge AI, 2026).

Agentic AI can be designed as a goal-oriented system that can make plans, use analytical tools, coordinate with other specialised agents, verify results and propose actions as conditions change.

In Agentic AI for Executives (Konverge AI, 2026), this approach is described through six core capabilities: perception, reasoning, planning, learning, verification and execution. Together, they form a working cycle that enables a system to respond more adaptively to its environment.

Applied to APBN management, these capabilities could form an Agentic Fiscal Orchestration System. It would not operate as a single algorithm determining all fiscal policy. Instead, several analytical agents would work according to their respective functions and be connected through an orchestration mechanism.

A Revenue Intelligence Agent would monitor state revenue, changes in economic activity and potential revenue risks. An Expenditure Productivity Agent would assess the relationship between spending allocations, programme outputs and development impacts.

A Debt and Fiscal Risk Agent would analyse financing, debt costs and contingent risks. An Investment Coordination Agent would identify links between the APBN and investment by SOEs, Danantara, banks and the private sector. A Regional Development Agent would map development gaps and financing needs across regions.

All these agents would operate through an orchestration layer that integrates information, compares scenarios, identifies policy conflicts and presents recommendations to authorised officials.

The most important change would not simply be faster data processing, but the ability to connect decisions that were previously analysed separately. Agentic AI could thus help shift fiscal coordination from a largely reactive process towards one that is more predictive and adaptive.

Nevertheless, Agentic AI must not replace the legitimacy of policymaking. It may misread data, rely on faulty assumptions or produce biased recommendations.

Decisions on taxation, subsidies, debt and APBN allocations must therefore remain within constitutional processes, supported by model testing, transparency and human oversight. The state remains the conductor; the APBN is its strategic instrument. Agentic AI helps read the economic score, detect discord and offer possible adjustments.

From fiscal space to Intelligent Fiscal Orchestration

Limited fiscal space is often seen as the main constraint on development financing. When revenue is limited and spending needs rise, policy choices can appear to be confined to raising taxes, cutting expenditure or taking on more debt.

Yet development is determined not only by fiscal space, but also by financing capacity and fiscal effectiveness. Fiscal space refers to the government’s capacity to implement policy without undermining the sustainability of public finances.

Financing capacity describes the ability to mobilise funds from different economic actors. Fiscal effectiveness, meanwhile, reflects the ability to turn government spending into development outcomes.

These three concepts must not be conflated. Financing from banks, SOEs, Danantara or private investors is not additional APBN revenue. But through investment coordination and appropriate risk-sharing, these sources of finance can complement state spending and expand its economic impact.

The APBN should no longer simply determine which projects receive funding, but also how each project connects to follow-on investment, industrial capacity, productive financing, markets and regional economies. Agentic AI could help identify these connections and detect when a link in the development chain is not progressing as planned.

For example, downstream cocoa development in Sulawesi could be treated as an integrated value-creation ecosystem. The APBN could support road and port connectivity, energy provision and improvements in human capital.

Investment by SOEs or Danantara, provided it meets their mandates and commercial viability requirements, could strengthen processing facilities. Banks could provide investment and working-capital financing for farmers, cooperatives, micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs) and industry. Local governments could improve licensing, production zones and workforce readiness.

Agentic AI could then help monitor the links between these components. If road construction is delayed, the system could identify potential effects on the industry’s operational timetable. If supplies of raw materials are insufficient, it could recommend adjusting production capacity or strengthening farmer support programmes. If demand for credit rises, it could help map financing gaps without replacing banks’ risk assessments.

The ultimate result would not simply be the completion of a government project, but the creation of a value chain extending from agricultural production and industrial processing to distribution and domestic and export markets. This is the difference between an APBN that funds development and one that orchestrates it.

From early warning to adaptive fiscal governance

Another benefit of Agentic AI is its ability to support early-warning systems and policy adjustment. Imagine a sharp rise in global oil prices. Under a conventional fiscal approach, the government would calculate the effects on subsidies, oil and gas revenue, and financing needs.

But energy pressures also affect inflation, purchasing power, industrial production costs, investment and economic growth. A multi-agent approach could analyse these impacts in parallel and then integrate them.

A revenue agent would estimate changes in state income. A spending agent would calculate subsidy and compensation needs. A fiscal-risk agent would examine the consequences for the deficit and financing. A growth agent would analyse the effects on consumption, investment and production. A regional development agent would identify the regions and population groups most affected.

The result would be a set of policy options, each accompanied by its consequences, assumptions and risks. In this way, Agentic AI would not make decisions in place of the government; it would strengthen the government’s ability to assess cross-sector consequences before policies are decided.

These projections would, of course, need to be backed by tested and auditable economic models. Sophisticated algorithms cannot replace high-quality data or sound economic judgement. This change could be described as adaptive fiscal governance: fiscal governance that not only plans and evaluates, but also learns from policy outcomes and adjusts implementation responsibly.

Indonesia is not starting from zero

Finance Minister Regulation No. 93 of 2024 on the Digital Platform for National Fiscal Policy Synergy provides for the integration of fiscal information from central and local government. The regulation also allows for the use of artificial intelligence in policy analysis and emphasises data interoperability, security and accountability.

A platform can integrate data without connecting decisions. A dashboard can display thousands of indicators without explaining the causal relationships between them. An AI system can even produce rapid but faulty recommendations if it is not supported by verifiable models.

Agentic AI development must therefore be part of a governance reform agenda, not merely a technology procurement project. The first stage could focus on data integration, performance monitoring and early-warning systems. The next could develop policy simulations and analysis of spending productivity. Following testing, the system could be expanded to support programme coordination across ministries and local governments.

The entire process requires consistent data standards, clear divisions of authority, information security, audit mechanisms and human oversight of system recommendations and actions. Success should be measured by the ability to improve decision quality, reduce programme duplication, speed up policy responses and deliver greater development impact.

The Orchestrator State in the age of artificial intelligence

Within the Orchestrator State framework, the government sets the direction of development. The APBN is the strategic instrument for mobilising resources and aligning priorities. Agentic AI provides the intelligence mechanisms that help connect policy information, decisions, implementation and evaluation.

The relationship between the three must be clear: state leadership sets the goals, the APBN drives development, and technology strengthens the state’s capacity to orchestrate.

A sound APBN safeguards fiscal sustainability. A productive APBN creates added value. An orchestrated APBN connects all development instruments. Agentic AI offers the prospect of making that orchestration smarter, more adaptive and measurable.

It is not enough for Indonesia to have a large, sound or digitised APBN. The country needs a budget capable of orchestrating all the forces of the national economy. The future of development will not be determined solely by how much the state spends, but by how intelligently it mobilises the country’s economic capacity.

More from 18 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/from-the-state-budget-to-intelligent-fiscal-orchestration-1792342223)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261018222628-14-777277/dari-apbn-ke-intelligent-fiscal-orchestration), translated from Indonesian
Print