From NU for Indonesia: Building a Meritocracy-Based Democracy
The decision of the 35th Nahdlatul Ulama Congress to renew the mechanism for electing the PBNU chairman, which culminated in the selection of KH Abdul Hakim Mahfudz for the 2026-2031 term, deserves appreciation as a constructive institutional breakthrough. This mechanism does not negate democracy, but seeks to improve its quality by combining the aspirations of participants, the tradition of deliberation, meritocracy, and the wisdom of the ulama.
Based on the agreed mechanism, the election of the PBNU Chairman is first pursued through consensus deliberation by congress participants. If consensus is not reached, participants still play an important role by shortlisting a maximum of five candidates. The five names with the greatest support are then submitted to the Ahlul Halli wal ’Aqdi (AHWA) to be selected as PBNU Chairman.
This model presents a balance between popular mandate and institutional wisdom. Congress participants remain the source of legitimacy because they determine who deserves to enter the top five. However, the final decision is not based solely on the number of votes, but also on a deeper assessment by ulama who are trusted to possess integrity, maturity, and understanding of the organisation’s needs.
Thus, the mechanism is not a reduction of voting rights, but a more proportional division of roles. Participants provide legitimacy, while the AHWA conducts the final assessment based on capacity, integrity, track record, ability to maintain unity, and the suitability of the candidate with the direction of NU’s struggle.
Democracy Does Not Stop at Voting
So far, democracy is often simplified into mere voting. Whoever obtains the most votes is automatically considered the most worthy to lead. In fact, popularity and electability do not always correlate directly with leadership capacity and quality.
A PBNU Chairman must possess managerial ability, a broad network, communication maturity, understanding of NU traditions and values, and the capability to face social, economic, political, and technological changes. He must also be able to build harmonious relations between syuriyah and tanfidziyah, central and regional levels, and senior and younger generations.
This is where the new mechanism becomes relevant. The popular vote still operates as a source of legitimacy, but receives a final touch in the form of a wisdom vote—rational, moral, and wise consideration from trusted individuals.
This mechanism can also reduce the tendency towards overly transactional elections. In a highly competitive system, an organisation risks being dragged into a contest that drains energy, forms prolonged factions, and places electoral victory above the interests of the organisation.
The involvement of the AHWA opens space for competition to remain within the corridors of adab, brotherhood, and the benefit of the jam’iyah. The election is not merely an arena for power struggles, but a process of finding the best figure to carry the organisation’s mandate.
Restoring Deliberation as the Main Path
Another aspect that deserves appreciation is the placement of consensus deliberation as the first option. This shows that NU does not merely adopt procedural democracy, but develops a democracy rooted in Islamic values and national culture.
Deliberation does not mean avoiding differences. On the contrary, deliberation acknowledges the existence of differences, then manages them through dialogue, magnanimity, and the willingness to place common interests above group interests.
Voting remains available when consensus is not reached. However, voting is used as a screening instrument, not the sole measure of truth and worthiness. This is a form of organisational maturity: the aspirations of the majority are respected, but wisdom and long-term benefit are still safeguarded.
This mechanism also shows that democracy does not have to follow a single uniform model. Every organisation has different history, values, structure, and needs. NU has both the right and the responsibility to build its leadership system based on the character and heritage of its organisation.
Learning from Muhammadiyah Too
The tradition of leadership selection in Muhammadiyah also provides an important lesson. The Congress elects 13 members of the Central Board from candidates who have gone through a screening process. Subsequently, the 13 elected members deliberate to propose and determine the Chairman, who is then confirmed by the congress forum.
In that model, participant support remains the basis of legitimacy. However, the position of Chairman is not automatically given to the person who obtains the most individual votes. The elected leaders deliberate again to determine the figure deemed most capable of leading collectively.
NU and Muhammadiyah have different traditions, structures, and organisational characters. Therefore, their mechanisms do not have to be identical. However, both demonstrate one important similarity: the election of leaders is not viewed solely as a competition to seek the most votes, but as a process of finding the best figure to carry the mandate.
The two largest Islamic organisations in Indonesia provide an example that democracy can operate alongside deliberation, collective leadership, organisational adab, and meritocracy. Differences do not have to end in division, while victory should not be the sole goal of an election process.
From Organisations Towards Regional Leadership
A model like this deserves further study as inspiration for leadership selection in Indonesia, not only within organisations but also in the recruitment process for regional heads.
Of course, its application cannot be copied wholesale because regional head elections operate within the framework of the constitution and statutory regulations. Article 18 paragraph (4) of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia affirms that governors, regents, and mayors are elected democratically.
However, its basic spirit can be adopted: the people remain the source of legitimacy, but the quality of candidates must be guaranteed through a more serious, transparent, and meritocracy-based selection process.
Regional democracy currently still faces various problems, ranging from high-cost politics, the dominance of popularity, pragmatism in candidacy, transactional politics, to the emergence of figures who have electability but do not necessarily possess adequate governmental capacity.
As a result, the political process often tests the ability to build image and gather resources more than the ability to understand problems and formulate policies for society.
Going forward, a layered selection mechanism can be considered before regional head candidates are offered to the people. Political parties or coalitions of political parties must open a transparent screening process. Candidates need to be tested on integrity, track record, understanding of regional conditions, managerial ability, and the quality of their vision and programmes.
An independent panel consisting of academics, community figures, professionals, and other credible elements can provide an open assessment of candidate quality. The result is not to take over popular sovereignty, but to serve as public consideration so that society does not choose based solely on popularity, billboards, financial strength, or momentary sentiment.
With such a design, direct elections can still be maintained, but preceded by a process that ensures the figures entering the ballot have met certain leadership standards. Popular legitimacy and candidate quality need not be opposed. Both must instead be combined.
Placing the Merit System as the Foundation
Indonesia needs a leadership recruitment system that is more oriented towards quality. A merit system in the context of leadership means providing opportunities based on ability, integrity, achievement, experience, and track record—not merely based on proximity, lineage, financial strength, or popularity.
Public leadership should not be viewed solely as the result of electoral competition. Leading a region requires the ability to formulate policy, manage budgets, build bureaucracy, attract investment, create jobs, maintain social stability, and deliver quality public services.
Therefore, regional head candidates should ideally possess measurable minimum competencies. The public also has the right to obtain objective information regarding the ability, integrity, programmes, and track record of each candidate. Quality democracy not only provides the right to vote, but also ensures that the people have quality choices.
This is the relevance of the lesson from NU and Muhammadiyah. Voter aspirations are still respected, but the election process does not stop at vote counting. There is room for deliberation, capacity assessment, collective leadership, and consideration of the long-term needs of the organisation and society.
Transparency Is the Key
The NU mechanism through the AHWA will be stronger if accompanied by open and trustworthy governance. The process of selecting AHWA members, the criteria for assessing candidates, the prevention of conflicts of interest, and the decision-making process need to be adequately explained to participants and NU members.
Transparency does not mean opening all sensitive internal dynamics. However, the organisation must ensure that decisions are taken independently, responsibly, and solely for the benefit of the jam’iyah.
AHWA members carry a very great mandate. They are not merely vote holders, but guardians of the trust of congress participants. Their decisions must be free from pressure, personal closeness, and short-term interests.
The same principle must be applied if the spirit of this mechanism is developed in public leadership recruitment. The panel or institution screening candidates must be independent, its criteria measurable, its process transparent, and its assessment results accessible to the public. Without transparency, the screening mechanism risks being perceived as a new oligarchy.
From NU and Muhammadiyah for Indonesia
The NU Congress decision demonstrates the courage to evaluate organisational mechanisms. Rule changes are not a regression as long as they are carried out legally, participatively, and directed towards strengthening leadership quality.
NU is providing a lesson that healthy democracy is not only about who wins and who loses. Democracy must be able to produce the best leaders, maintain unity after elections, and ensure the organisation continues to move towards its great goals.
Together with Muhammadiyah’s election tradition, this mechanism can serve as learning material for the development of Indonesian democracy. We need a democracy that still respects the people’s voice, but does not ignore competence, integrity, experience, and wisdom.
Ultimately, an election is not merely a process of determining who is most popular. An election is a path to ensure that the mandate falls to the right person—not only the one who obtains the most votes, but the one who is most worthy, most capable, and most needed.
From NU and Muhammadiyah, Indonesia can learn to build a more mature democracy: a democracy that is civilised, of high quality, and based on meritocracy. For the future of organisations and regions cannot be entrusted solely to leaders who are only capable of winning elections. We need leaders who possess competence, integrity, maturity, and real ability to exercise leadership and deliver benefit to society.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/from-nu-for-indonesia-building-a-meritocracy-based-democracy-1788148264)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260831094305-14-763549/dari-nu-untuk-indonesia-membangun-demokrasi-berbasis-meritokrasi), translated from Indonesian