From Iraq to Iran: Why America Repeats the Mistakes of Endless War
In international politics, nothing appears more tempting yet more painful than the strategic mirage that superpowers continue to chase—the illusion that they possess absolute control and can resolve historic conflicts with a single push of a button or a lightning strike.
In the ongoing war against Iran, the issue is not merely the cost of military confrontation or turmoil in energy markets.
There is a far larger question concerning the future of American power: has America lost the ability to resist the allure of war, even when it has known the risks from the very beginning?
That is the central question posed by Emma Ashford, a senior fellow in the Reimagining US Grand Strategy programme at the Stimson Center, in her analysis published in Foreign Affairs under the title ‘America’s Fatal Attraction to War’, as cited by Al Jazeera on Friday (14/8/2026).
Meanwhile, Politico’s foreign affairs correspondent Nahal Toosi, in her analysis, assesses that Washington has slipped into a new quagmire reminiscent of its involvement in Iraq—but this time in a far more dangerous international environment.
In her article, Ashford observes a great irony. Donald Trump returned to the White House presenting himself as the president who would end ‘endless wars’.
Indeed, the first year of his second term at times gave signs that American foreign policy would genuinely undergo change.
Trump pressed European allies to increase defence spending, pushed for peace negotiations between Russia and Ukraine, and sought to ease tensions with China over Taiwan.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/from-iraq-to-iran-why-america-repeats-the-mistakes-of-endless-war-1786668685)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/tjqh9x320/dari-irak-ke-iran-mengapa-amerika-mengulangi-kesalahan-perang-panjang), translated from Indonesian