From authoritarianism to democracy
From authoritarianism to democracy
The following is the second of a two part article, an excerpt
from an address by State Minister of Investment/State Enterprises
Laksamana Sukardi before an international conference transition
and globalization. The conference was hosted by the Institute of
Security and International Studies, Chulalongkorn University in
Bangkok, Thailand on Dec 18.
BANGKOK (JP): A final problem in Indonesia's transition
process is our deeply rooted culture of corruption. These corrupt
practices have been cultivated for decades, and the grip of
corruption on Indonesian society remains strong. Elites and
bureaucrats have been on the payrolls of cronies for a long time,
and we still see and feel the effects today.
It should be mentioned that the cronies and the franchisees
played a very interesting role in our democracy movement. The
movement was driven by People Power while also led and encouraged
by elite reformers. But except for Golkar, which had a huge war
chest going into the elections, most of the other parties
desperately needed money.
It turns out that business people who had been working with
the status quo spent a lot of money on the opposition. Some of
this money was offered as a genuine expression of a desire for
change. But a lot of it was an effort to buy favor and to be able
to call in debts if the status quo government indeed fell.
This arrangement has severely constrained the will of the
reform parties now in the coalition government to take actions
against corrupt supporters from only a few months before.
A key question is how to address systemic corruption. There is
what we might call the "forward-looking" approach. This is the
view that when corruption is so systemic, the best solution is to
establish new practices from now on, because if you go after the
corruptors of the past, the whole society will get dragged into a
long and painful process.
Others argue that one cannot make a fresh start on corruption
for the future without dealing with corruption from the past.
It's partly a matter of credibility and accountability. But it's
also the fact that many of the effects of corruption from the
past hang over today as burdens on the society who must pay the
costs of cleaning up the mess.
The answer on how to proceed, I think, is a blend of both
approaches. As a first principle, we cannot ignore cases of
corruption that involve a shift of financial burdens and losses
to the public -- whether state-owned banks or the massive new
debts the Indonesian public has been forced to take on for
banking and corporate restructuring through IBRA.
But we must also be forward looking because we do not want to
destroy our entire economy as we deal with the crimes of the
past. When corruption is deeply rooted, pulling out the roots can
also damage the soil.
The entire effort is severely compromised by the fact that
more so in Indonesia than in other countries that have had
transitions, the entire government is still run by bureaucrats
who in spirit and practice still want to serve the top people of
the previous regime. This makes it very hard to get immediate
responsiveness from the government apparatus for change.
It is important to keep in mind that this is a process that is
assessed day by day, week by week, case by case. It is a mistake
to set a threshold of how far you can or should go in advance. No
one knows what the realm of the possible is until you reach the
actual limits. Setting the boundaries too conservatively in
advance can rob the people of much more change and accountability
than they could have achieved.
Indonesia is in the middle of a very fragile transition. We
must and will deal with the independence movements. We are fully
aware of the territorial challenges we face and are taking
concrete steps to handle them.
One aspect of granting greater regional autonomy that rarely
gets mentioned is that the outer regions themselves are not
prepared institutionally for autonomous rule. If the central
government grants regional autonomy without proper preparation in
the regions, we could face a dangerous situation such as in
Russia where regional warlords spring up. This could potentially
produce for us hundreds of derivative Soehartos on a petty scale
running their own local corrupt regimes. This is obviously
something that should be avoided, even if it means the process of
granting regional autonomy must be slowed down to make sure it is
done prudently.
We are undertaking our transition in an era of much greater
transparency and scrutiny than Indonesia has ever known. Our
press is free and the role of the internet at every stage of this
movement, especially for the student activist networks, has been
vitally important. The international pressure on Indonesia has
also been significant, especially through financial institutions
and the media.
What does Indonesia need to maintain stability during this
transition?
We need a credible and professional government and leadership
based upon democratic elections. We are now in the process of
convincing the people that this is what we have put in place
since Oct. 20 of this year.
We also need to move forward with a prudent and timely
regional autonomy process.
Judicial reform is another priority, and a key element to
solving our restructuring challenges.
Establishing a clean government is also crucial -- otherwise
we will enter into a vicious downward cycle of corruption and de-
legitimation.
Institution-building in the areas of law, economy, and
democracy is another high priority for us if we are to keep the
momentum of our transition going.
In the end, what Indonesia needs more than anything is not a
strong government, but rather a strong civil society -- the
creation of an open society. We have a good start, and despite
all the challenges facing President Gus Dur and Vice President
Megawati, we are optimistic we can face the obstacles that we
inherited from the previous authoritarian regime.
Our democratic elections have given this government a great
deal of good will from the Indonesian people and the
international community.
And yet the global community poses as many threats as it does
comforts. The trend toward a more open trade and investment
regime means that Indonesia cannot stand still contemplating its
problems. We face highly productive and competitive global
companies, and that means our own firms must become as efficient
and competitive.
But we cannot only focus on being competitive. There must be
accountability for corporations also. Indonesia was the victim of
a corrupt authoritarian regime that was enthusiastically
supported by global business and multilateral financial
institutions.
We Indonesians are confronting and digesting the domestic
lessons from our experience over the past three decades. But at
the international level there are also important lessons to be
learned. We need universal laws and practices on good corporate
behavior, and as a part of that, a functioning and enforced
international standard modeled on the U.S. Foreign Corrupt
Practices Act.
I like to fulfill promises, whether political promises of my
own party to take the rule of law seriously, or my personal
promise to end on an upbeat note. So let me conclude with a word
of optimism.
First, Indonesia will survive the challenges we face today. Of
this I am confident. The key is how we will move forward, not if
we will move forward. And we will do so in tandem with our
friends and allies in the ASEAN region and beyond, who are also
facing both challenges and opportunities in the months and years
ahead.
But whatever challenges we face, it is important to recognize
that we are living in an era of transitions that many of us did
not think we would see in our lifetimes. Democracies -- even if
they are imperfect democracies -- are growing in number, while
military and one-party states are retreating around the globe.
We are not making our transitions all at the same time or with
the same success. But the global trend is clear and it gives us
good reason for optimism.
More from 28 December 1999 โ
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/from-authoritarianism-to-democracy-1447893297-1422663)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post