Fresh Wind for Directors: Danantara Brings Legal Shield to Encourage Business Innovation
Imagine leading a company with trillions of rupiah in assets, yet every strategic decision you make carries the potential for imprisonment. This has been the dilemma haunting the directors of State-Owned Enterprises (SOE) in Indonesia for years.
Now, the emergence of the Daya Anagata Nusantara Investment Management Agency (BPI Danantara) brings a breath of fresh air through the implementation of the Business Judgment Rule (BJR), a legal doctrine believed to serve as a shield for SOE managers to innovate without excessive fear.
However, can this legal protection truly distinguish between failed business decisions and criminal acts of corruption? This crucial question emerged during a Round Table Discussion (RTD) hosted by the Nagara Institute, titled ‘Re-designing SOEs via Danantara and Legal Traps: The Responsibility of Directors and Commissioners’.
Satya Arinanto, a researcher at the Nagara Institute, explained that protection for SOE directors currently has a solid legal foundation through three main regulations. First, Law Number 16 of 2025 regarding the Fourth Amendment to Law Number 19 of 2003 concerning SOEs. Second, Law Number 40 of 2007 regarding Limited Liability Companies (PT). Third, Law Number 21 of 2021 regarding the Amendment to Law Number 31 of 1999 concerning the Eradication of Corruption Crimes.
“The primary goal of the Business Judgment Rule concept is to protect directors from liability for business decisions made. Directors cannot be blamed as long as their decisions do not involve elements of fraud, conflicts of interest, or unlawful acts,” Satya asserted.
The latest regulation in Law Number 16 of 202lar even reinforces the paradigm of asset management based on pure limited liability company principles, affirming that company wealth is officially a separate asset from the state financial domain.
“Although wealth is separated, supervision and audits of the company are still conducted as part of the management of state-owned assets. However, directors proven to have committed legal violations must certainly be processed according to the regulations,” he added.
A strong statement was made by the former President Director of PT Merpati Nusantara Airlines, Hotasi Nababan. He highlighted the real clash between two different legal regimes that have long shackled SOE managers.
“We live in two different regimes that cannot mix, much like oil and water in one container. If even a single penny from the State Budget (APBN) enters, it automatically becomes part of the state financial domain subject to audit by the BPK (Audit Board of Indonesia),” he said.
Hotasi emphasised that as long as the legal construction remains as it is, SOE directors remain in a very vulnerable position. “As long as the legal construction remains as it is, half a foot of state company managers is already in prison. Therefore, distinguish between corruption and poor performance so that directors are willing to take risks to drive the real economy,” he explained.
Consequently, he requested BPI Danantara to provide a more robust legal umbrella to support the achievement of the 8% national economic growth target. This protection is urgent so that professionals have the courage to execute various strategic investment plans optimally.
Amidst the euphoria of SOE transformation, Lalola Easter Kaban, Program Manager of Indonesia Corruption Watch (ICW), reminded that the formation of BPI Danantara as a new superholding must prioritise the principle of public accountability.
“We are talking about a new entity, a superholding that intends to mimic Singapore’s Temasek Holdings. We must be careful and closely monitor this process to ensure the new institution does not turn into a case like Malaysia’s 1MDB,” she said.
Lalola emphasised that the application of the Business Judgment Rule can only be effective if all potential conflicts of interest are managed transparently. Synchronisation of material regulations is absolutely necessary so that legal instruments are not misused to criminalise pure management decisions.
“We must all clearly understand that the occurrence of state losses is not the same as an act of corruption. The Business Judgment Rule is certainly the best way to minimise the aggressiveness of the application of the Corruption Eradication Law in the field,” she said.
Academics assess that the consolidation of SOE entities by Danantara strengthens efficiency, governance, and economic competitiveness. The transformation of SOEs is beginning to impact the profits of Pelindo, Pupuk Indonesia, PLN, Pertamina, and Himbara banks.
Danantara emphasises that the separation of assets and investments is key to managing risk and maintaining global investor confidence. President Prabowo Subianto plans to close up to 800 unhealthy SOEs as a step towards efficiency, budget savings, and the eradication of corruption in state-owned enterprises.
Pupuk Indonesia ranked 68th with audited revenue of Rp90.4 trillion, growing by 10% compared to the previous year.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/fresh-wind-for-directors-danantara-brings-legal-shield-to-encourage-business-innovation-1782485494)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/ekonomi/904815/angin-segar-bagi-direksi-danantara-hadirkan-perisai-hukum-agar-tak-takut-berbisnis), translated from Indonesian