Forty Figures File Amicus Curiae Brief for Former Ombudsman Chief
Jakarta (ANTARA) – Forty national figures have submitted an amicus curiae, or “friend of the court” brief, for Hery Susanto, former chair of the Ombudsman of the Republic of Indonesia, during a hearing at the Central Jakarta District Court’s Corruption Court on Thursday.
Amicus curiae spokesperson Hasrul Harahap handed the document to presiding judge Dwi Elyarahma Sulistiowati and panel members Fajar Kusuma Aji and Alfis Setiawan.
He said the document sets out legal views urging the judges to examine every element of the charges in light of the facts established at trial and admissible evidence.
The 40 contributors include academics, legal practitioners, leaders of civil society organisations, activists and public policy observers.
Among them are Fadli Nasution; Abdul Haris, rector of Tasikmalaya Islamic University for the 2022–2026 term; Hasrul Harahap, dean of the Faculty of Social and Political Sciences at Jakarta University; Dilla Novita, head of the State Administration Studies programme at Unisma; Suratman; Asep Supriatna; Robi Anugerah Marpaung; Derwanto; Ahmad Fauzan; and Yusak Farhan.
Hasrul said the brief was not an attempt to interfere with the judicial process, but an independent contribution of legal thought intended to provide the panel with an additional perspective in assessing the case.
The amici stressed that a criminal conviction must not be based merely on assumptions, social relationships or administrative events.
They said the judges should determine whether the defendant’s conduct meets every element of the criminal offences alleged by the prosecution.
They also cited the principle of in dubio pro reo—that reasonable doubt in the assessment of evidence must be resolved in the defendant’s favour.
Hasrul said any conviction must therefore rest on evidence meeting the legal standard, rather than suspicion or pressure from public opinion.
On that basis, the amici asked the panel to accept and consider their legal opinion, assess all the evidence fully and independently, and find Hery not guilty if prosecutors fail to prove the elements of their charges.
“We also ask the panel to acquit him (vrijspraak) if the legal requirements for such a decision are met,” he said.
Hasrul said the submission was part of efforts to promote law enforcement grounded in evidence and the protection of defendants’ rights.
The strength of criminal law, he said, lies in the state’s ability to prove a person’s guilt before depriving them of their liberty, not in how easily someone can be convicted.
Previously, prosecutors sought a five-year-and-six-month prison sentence for Hery, along with a Rp300 million fine, with 100 days’ imprisonment in lieu of payment.
They also sought an order requiring him to repay Rp4.19 billion, with a three-year prison term in lieu of payment.
In the alleged corruption case concerning the management of the nickel-mining business for the 2021–2026 period, Hery is accused of receiving bribes worth a total of Rp4.85 billion in cash and property while serving as an Ombudsman RI member from 2021 to 2026.
The alleged bribes were intended to induce Hery, then an Ombudsman member, to manipulate the Ombudsman’s Investigation Report (LHP).
The alleged manipulation was intended to have the LHP state that the Environment and Forestry Ministry’s assessment of non-tax state revenue (PNBP) obligations for the use of forest areas (PKH) imposed on PT Thosida Indonesia and PT Dinamika Sejahtera Mandiri constituted maladministration.
The report was also allegedly to state that the rejection of applications to upgrade exploration mining business permits (IUP) to production-operation permits for PT Mitra Kumala Energi and PT Gold Telen River constituted maladministration.
Specifically, Hery is alleged to have received Rp675 million from Laode Sinarwan Oda, director of PT Thosida Indonesia, through Lukman Malanuang, with the payment delivered via Edi Sukandi.
He is also alleged to have received Rp200 million from Tjia Peng Tjoan, also known as Peng, director of PT Dinamika Sejahtera Mandiri, through Lukman Malanuang.
In addition, Agung Winarno allegedly provided a house in Pulo Gebang Permai, Jakarta, valued at Rp2.2 billion; Rp1.2 billion through Edi Sukandi; and a further Rp525 million.
The indictment also alleges that Hery received Rp50 million from Muhammad Rozai, a representative of PT Mitra Kumala Energi, through Agung Winarno.
Hery has been charged under Article 12(a) or Article 12(b), or Article 5(2) in conjunction with Article 18 of the Corruption Eradication Law, or Article 606(2) of the National Criminal Code in conjunction with Article 2(8) of Appendix I, point 28, and Article VII, point 49, of the Criminal Penalty Adjustment Law.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/forty-figures-file-amicus-curiae-brief-for-former-ombudsman-chief-1792684303)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5806087/sebanyak-40-tokoh-ajukan-amicus-curiae-untuk-eks-ketua-ombudsman), translated from Indonesian