Former Trade Minister Alleges Foreign Interference; IDX Chief Says Index Providers Are Independent
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia – The Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX) has responded to claims by former Indonesian Trade Minister Muhammad Lutfi, who alleged that foreign parties were manoeuvring to pressure Morgan Stanley Capital International (MSCI) into downgrading Indonesia’s equity market from Emerging Market to Standalone Market.
IDX President Director Jeffrey Hendrik said the exchange was focusing on technical matters related to improvements and reforms in the capital market. Nevertheless, he said he remained confident in the independence of global index providers such as MSCI.
“We have always believed, and continue to believe, that global index providers are independent. Therefore, we will focus on the technical steps we can take to reform the capital market,” Jeffrey told reporters on Tuesday, 20 October 2026.
Former Trade Minister Lutfi, who served in 2024 and from 2020 to 2022, had earlier highlighted MSCI’s plan to hold a consultation on the possibility of downgrading Indonesia’s equity market from Emerging Market to Standalone Market. He said the development warranted scrutiny because it could affect investors’ perceptions of Indonesia’s capital market.
In his view, the issue was not simply Indonesia’s position in global market classifications, but also involved economic interests and control of strategic national assets. Standalone Market status is often associated with limited access for international investors, including restrictions on capital flows, or capital controls.
Lutfi also outlined what he believed lay behind the proposed reclassification. He said Indonesia did not implement capital controls of the kind he described, and alleged that Singaporean investment institutions, including Temasek and the Government of Singapore Investment Corporation (GIC), had put pressure on MSCI.
He named GIC’s Rachel Goh, whom he alleged had pushed for Indonesia’s equity market to be downgraded.
“I even heard directly from people inside that Rachel Goh at GIC was angry and pressuring MSCI to downgrade Indonesia’s rating. Come on, Rachel, don’t you know walls in Jakarta do talk and scream?” he said in a post on Instagram on Tuesday, 20 October 2026.
The allegation of pressure has not been supported by independently verifiable evidence. Any alleged involvement by Singaporean investment institutions in MSCI’s classification process therefore requires further confirmation from the parties concerned.
Lutfi also said the issues raised by MSCI were linked to conditions within Indonesia’s capital market, including the transparency of share ownership and the conduct of some listed companies. He nevertheless suspected that other interests lay behind the current developments.
“The reason being used is the behaviour of a handful of our own conglomerate issuers,” he said.
According to Lutfi, foreign investors’ withdrawal from the Indonesian equity market should not automatically be interpreted as a sign that the domestic capital market’s fundamentals have deteriorated. He argued that if share prices did not fall significantly after foreign investors sold their holdings, those who had exited would find it difficult to return at lower prices.
He then suggested that the threat of a change in market classification could cause investor panic and depress domestic share prices. In the scenario he described, this could create an opportunity for well-capitalised investors to buy leading Indonesian shares back at cheaper prices.
However, there is no verified evidence that the threat of an MSCI reclassification is being deliberately used to depress share prices so that domestic assets can be bought back. MSCI’s decision should be assessed in light of its index methodology, consultations with market participants, and evaluation of the accessibility and investability of Indonesia’s equity market.
Lutfi urged the public not to become divided over the capital-market developments. He said national interests should remain a priority amid mounting pressure on the domestic stock market.
“This is about who controls Indonesia’s wealth. We must stand together, we must be patriotic, and we must protect our nation’s dignity,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/former-trade-minister-alleges-foreign-interference-idx-chief-says-index-providers-are-independent-1792500659)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/market/20261020171605-17-777934/eks-mendag-tuding-manuver-asing-bos-bei-indeks-provider-independen), translated from Indonesian