Former KPU Chief Tells Doli Kurnia: ‘Forgetting Is Allowed, Hypocrisy Is Not’
Former General Elections Commission (KPU) chief Hasyim Asy’ari has rejected allegations that Article 18(3) of KPU Regulation No. 19/2023 on the nomination of candidates for the 2024 presidential election was never discussed and had been inserted surreptitiously.
Hasyim took aim at Ahmad Doli Kurnia, a member of the House of Representatives’ Commission II, who said the article had never been discussed by the KPU and Commission II. At the time, Doli was chair of the commission.
“Several media reports have quoted Ahmad Doli Kurnia as saying that he never discussed the revision of Article 18(3) of KPU Regulation No. 19/2023 on the nomination of presidential and vice-presidential candidates at a parliamentary hearing with the Government, KPU, Bawaslu and DKPP. That statement needs to be rebutted and clarified,” Hasyim said when contacted on Monday (12 October).
Hasyim explained that on 19 September 2023, the KPU wrote to the House requesting consultations on four draft KPU regulations, attaching the drafts under discussion, including the draft regulation on the nomination of presidential and vice-presidential candidates.
A parliamentary hearing was then held on 20 September to consult on the draft regulations.
He said Article 18(3) of KPU Regulation No. 19/2023 was among the provisions discussed in the draft. It had initially appeared as Article 19(2). The Election Supervisory Agency (Bawaslu) also submitted comments on the draft regulation.
Those attending the hearing included Ahmad Doli Kurnia Tandjung, then chair of Commission II, and Arsul Sani, who is now a Constitutional Court justice, Hasyim said.
He said the draft’s provisions had been jointly approved as the hearing’s conclusions, with the document signed by the heads of the institutions involved, including Doli.
“The document approving the conclusions of the hearing on draft KPU Regulation No. 19/2023 was signed by Commission II chair Ahmad Doli Kurnia Tandjung, KPU chair Hasyim Asy’ari, Bawaslu member (acting chair) Herwyn Jefler Hielsa Malonda, DKPP chair Heddy Lugito, and the Home Ministry’s director-general for politics and public administration, Bahtiar,” he said.
Hasyim said the available information, data and documents showed that the article was known to many people, had been discussed jointly and had been approved by all parties.
“The allegation that the article was smuggled in or manipulated is untrue,” he said.
He added that no participant at the hearing had registered an objection to the provision.
The election organisers—the KPU, Bawaslu and the Election Organisers’ Ethics Council (DKPP)—attended and actively participated in discussions on the draft regulation, he said. Bawaslu and the DKPP had also signed the approval of the hearing’s conclusions.
“Ahmad Doli Kurnia Tandjung attended and chaired the hearing, and signed the approval of its conclusions. Arsul Sani, then a Commission II member and now a Constitutional Court justice, also attended,” he said.
Hasyim said responsibility for the inclusion of Article 18(3) of KPU Regulation No. 19/2023 rested jointly with the hearing’s participants.
He urged the DKPP to handle complaints concerning the article fairly and proportionately, with care and without conflicts of interest, noting that it had taken part in the hearing and signed off on its conclusions.
Hasyim also referred to remarks by Arsul during a recent hearing on election-result disputes, where the provision was discussed.
“I am imagining the angels Munkar and Nakir, as mentioned by Constitutional Court Justice Arsul Sani during the second round of election-result hearings, asking Ahmad Doli Kurnia and Arsul Sani: Did you attend the discussion of the draft regulation? Did you know that it contained the disputed article? Did you take part in approving it? I think we all know what Ahmad Doli Kurnia and Constitutional Court Justice Arsul Sani would answer to that series of questions from the angels,” Hasyim said.
He then quoted a hadith narrated by Imam Bukhari and Imam Muslim on the authority of Abu Hurairah about hypocrites.
“So on this occasion, I want to say to everyone: forgetting is allowed; hypocrisy is not,” he said.
Ahmad Doli Kurnia, who chaired Commission II from 2019 to 2024, had previously said that Article 18(3) was not in the regulation discussed at the meeting between the commission and the KPU.
“To the best of my knowledge, that clause was not there. But, again, I am checking with various people, including colleagues in the secretariat, because what we discussed at the time was purely the change concerning the Constitutional Court,” he said.
Bambang Widjojanto, a lawyer for Denny Indrayana and others, had earlier criticised Article 18(3) of KPU Regulation No. 19/2023 on the nomination of candidates for the presidential and vice-presidential election.
His criticism came after the Constitutional Court ruled inadmissible a petition challenging the validity of the educational qualifications of Indonesian Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka when he was nominated for the 2024 election.
Bambang argued that the article had been specifically designed for Gibran’s vice-presidential candidacy in the 2024 election, and that the KPU had drafted it to enable him to qualify.
“There is a criticism that needs to be brought before the Constitutional Court. Article 18(3) is very much the ‘Gibran article’, and that ‘Gibran article’ was passed through the General Elections Commission,” Bambang said at the court on Tuesday (6 October).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/former-kpu-chief-tells-doli-kurnia-forgetting-is-allowed-hypocrisy-is-not-1791766294)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261012062000-32-1414215/eks-ketua-kpu-sentil-doli-kurnia-soal-pkpu-lupa-boleh-munafik-jangan), translated from Indonesian