Former KPU Chief Rebukes Doli and Arsul over PKPU 19/2023: Forgetting Is Acceptable, Hypocrisy Is Not
Hasyim Asy’ari, who chaired the General Elections Commission (KPU) during the 2024 election, has taken a swipe at House of Representatives Commission II member Ahmad Doli Kurnia and Constitutional Court (MK) Justice Arsul Sani over allegations that a provision was secretly inserted into KPU Regulation (PKPU) No. 19/2023. The controversy concerns requirements for Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s vice-presidential candidacy in 2024. Hasyim said people could forget, but should not be hypocritical.
Hasyim initially rejected Doli’s claim that he had never discussed Article 18(3) of PKPU 19/2023, saying Doli had taken part in discussions on the provision.
“Several media reports have quoted Ahmad Doli Kurnia as saying that he ‘never discussed the revision of Article 18(3) of PKPU 19/2023 on the nomination of presidential and vice-presidential candidates at a House working meeting with the Government, KPU, Elections Supervisory Agency (Bawaslu) and Election Organisers Ethics Council (DKPP)’. This statement needs to be rebutted and clarified so that we all understand what happened at that meeting,” Hasyim said in a statement on Sunday (11 October 2026).
Hasyim stressed that Doli and Arsul Sani had both taken part in the working meeting discussing PKPU 19/2023. He said the meeting’s conclusions were signed by several officials, including Doli.
“The document approving the conclusions of the working meeting on the draft PKPU 19/2023 was signed by House Commission II chairman Ahmad Doli Kurnia Tandjung, KPU chairman Hasyim Asy’ari, Bawaslu member (acting chairman) Herwyn Jefler Hielsa Malonda, DKPP chairman Heddy Lugito, and the Home Affairs Ministry’s Director General of Politics and General Administration, Bahtiar,” he said.
He also noted that Arsul Sani, now an MK justice, attended the meeting. “Those present included the then-chairman of House Commission II, Ahmad Doli Kurnia Tandjung, and Arsul Sani, who is now an MK justice,” he added.
Hasyim concluded that Article 18(3), which has been accused of being secretly inserted, was discussed and approved by all parties. He also said no participant had recorded an objection to the provision.
“The accusations of ‘secretly inserting a provision’ and ‘manipulating a provision’ are untrue. None of the participants recorded an objection to the article,” he said.
He added that all election-organising bodies—the KPU, Bawaslu and DKPP—had attended and actively discussed Article 18(3) of PKPU 19/2023. He said responsibility for the provision’s inclusion was therefore shared.
“I am imagining the angels Munkar and Nakir, as in MK Justice Arsul Sani’s account during the second round of the election dispute hearings, asking Ahmad Doli Kurnia Tandjung and Arsul Sani: ‘Were you present to discuss the draft PKPU? Did you know the draft contained the disputed provision? Did you approve it?’ I think we all know what Ahmad Doli Kurnia Tandjung and MK Justice Arsul Sani would answer to those questions,” he said.
Hasyim then referred to a hadith transmitted by Imam Bukhari and Imam Muslim from Abu Hurairah, which he said concerns hypocrisy.
“For that reason, I would like to urge everyone: forgetting is acceptable, hypocrisy is not,” he said.
Doli Kurnia and Arsul Sani have been contacted for comment on Hasyim’s statement. They had not responded by the time this article was published.
Doli investigates alleged insertion of provision in PKPU 19/2023
Earlier, Ahmad Doli Kurnia, a member of House Commission II who chaired the commission in 2023, said he was investigating the origins of Article 18(3) in KPU Regulation No. 19/2023. The provision has come under scrutiny amid allegations that the KPU inserted it to clear the way for Gibran Rakabuming Raka.
The provision was questioned by MK justices Enny Nurbaningsih and Saldi Isra during a court hearing on Wednesday (30 September 2026). PKPU 19/2023, concerning the nomination of presidential and vice-presidential election candidates, replaced PKPU No. 22/2018 and contains 68 articles.
Hasyim Asy’ari signed the regulation on 9 October 2023 while serving as KPU chairman. It covers various matters, including the documents required of presidential and vice-presidential candidates.
Doli said he was tracing the origins of Article 18(3), having heard claims that it had been secretly inserted.
“This is something that will have to be proved. I am also trying to find out. There has been news that Article 18(3) was secretly inserted, as people are saying. I am gathering information and documents because I was the Commission II chairman at the time,” Doli told reporters at the House on Thursday (8 October).
He said PKPU 19/2023 had been discussed twice in the House. The first discussion took place in September, before the MK issued Decision No. 90 concerning the age limit.
According to Doli, the regulation was discussed again after the court’s decision. He said Article 18(3) was absent from both discussions.
“So, as far as I know, in my understanding, that paragraph was not there,” he added.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/former-kpu-chief-rebukes-doli-and-arsul-over-pkpu-19-2023-forgetting-is-acceptable-hypocrisy-is-not-1791694240)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8701778/eks-ketua-kpu-sindir-doli-arsul-soal-pkpu-19-2023-lupa-boleh-munafik-jangan), translated from Indonesian